The reason why many international fans are criticizing the current version of Barcelona is because of how we play, which is neither entertaining nor effective against top tier teams.
In my opinion, here’s why:
Our main attribute as a team focuses on nullifying the tempo of a game rather than controlling an attack-focused tempo that is difficult to overcome for the opposition. This works against less talented opposition, but as soon as a team has superior tactics than our own, we fail to do what we do best… break our opponent’s momentum and nullify the tempo of the game. This is effective but very very dull to watch.
Point is, Christensen, Araujo, Kounde, De Jong, Pedri, Gavi, implement the aforementioned game plan very very well. Break the tempo of the game. And when we score the first goal, it’s game on. But what happens when our opponent scores the first goal?
The problem is….
that there’s a disconnect between our midfield and our attack. And this is a result of tactics… which Xavi is responsible for implementing. Our attacks are oftentimes slow, predictable, and dependent on individual talent. We lack combination play between the midfield and the attack, and transitions are oftentimes slow and/or non-existent. We fail to attack from the center of the pitch, pass the ball forward in tight spaces, and do so quickly in order to overwhelm the opposition. Our midfield has been instructed to play the damn ball out to the wings, which the opponent expects, and defends with 2-3 players against our wingers, nullifying the threat. The ball returns to the midfield and out to a winger on the other side. Rinse and repeat.
Thru balls are essentially non-existent, for we are seldom in a position to implement them. There’s a disconnect between our midfield and attack. Combination play, tactics, and purpose should be instilled in the players, where each player does not even think about what to do next. Habit takes over. It just happens. With one objective in mind, to score a goal, as quickly as possible, with as little predictability as possible. All players should pose a threat. All angles should pose a danger for the opposition. And in order for this to occur, we need a manager who understands tactics in and out, ala Guardiola. This is not Xavi. Not now. Maybe in 10 years?
And it’s not a coincidence that our entire attack is underperforming. It has little to do with talent, and everything to do with what I described above. A does not know what B is doing or wants to do. Cross and inshallah, that’s as far as our attacking tactics go.