What? ...he's been our best player in the middle this season by far. I can kind of understand what you mean from a defensive point of view, but believe me if you have seen him this season he's more than capable at that too. He played left back for us one game and got man of the match. Not sure if you watched the Chelsea game but he ran the show. Its gona be tough whoever plays there, but if there is one player who can produce magic from the middle against Barca then its Giggs. That said, if it was Carrick and Fletcher, I'd be quite happy because a fresh Giggs coming on as sub could be very dangerous for us.