Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    142

Messigician

Senior Member
Yikes he threw Garcia under the bus

Q- After coaching Joan Garcia, what's the thing you're surprised most about him? And is he one of the best you've ever coached?

🚨🎙️| Flick: "This isn't an easy question, because I was the coach for both Neuer and Marc. Both of them are great keepers.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Yeah that is what it will be and he was probably absolutely raging at the game not being put to bed in second half and then Alaves going close to scoring a few times at end.

There was never much meaningful control of game.

First half was a chaotic shit show.

Second half for first half hour was better but cant remember too many good chances then at end of half when Alaves pressed it was panic stations and no control whatsoever.

There is a definite nervousness in the team at moment.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Flick is like "all I'm asking is for you guys to be perfect all the time, so we don't concede, is it that hard". Lol.

If other coaches had ever gotten so emo on the bench, OMG lol
 

Barcaman

Administrator
Staff member
Yikes he threw Garcia under the bus

Q- After coaching Joan Garcia, what's the thing you're surprised most about him? And is he one of the best you've ever coached?

🚨🎙️| Flick: "This isn't an easy question, because I was the coach for both Neuer and Marc. Both of them are great keepers.

It's typical Catalan small minded village bias from brainless press.
Hype up any Catalan player and then expect coaches to agree with them and put them higher than all times best.

Joan is doing great but he played 10 matches here and they want Flick to put him higher than Neuer.

Catalan press are doing a massive disservice to all these players.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
This YouTuber points out what I saw in the 2nd half, at time stamp 4:40.

The team was much better from the start of the 2nd half, and it wasn't all due to Pedri, who only came in at 60th minute, dropping olmo deeper for bernal. adding some much needed stability and we were playing a very mature game, waiting for the opportunities instead of taking unnecessary risk.

They created a few chances at the end, but this is barce under flick that's always doing to happen.

I was personally encouraged by the 2nd half and raphinha being back, not sure why he was being emo to be honest, a few good things to take for this game.

 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
The team were poor in first half and in second half improved but still largely poor and not doing much with possession had.. which results in nervy last 10/15 minutes when Alaves push up.

There is zero chance Flick thinks that first 30 min in second half was good, controlled football as it was not going anywhere and nervy finish came.

Second half v this lot last season once Casado had his regular hooking at HT was much much better.
 

FCBarca

Truth
Yep, great interview from him too - what a person & coach, very happy & fortunate to have him at the helm

Gracies Joan!
His integrity is plain to see and always important to keep things in context where the German is precise in what he conveys. He is regularly baited on RM topics which he consistently & resolutely swats away, yet Spanish 'journalists' have learned little or are simply forced to repeatedly use this shit stirring line of questioning

On Araujo, he asked for privacy and that it is a private matter - agree with him & Laporta, the culture we live in is embarrassing the way player has been abused. On flip side, very concerning going forward for a player to be mentally shook in such a high pressure position considering the responsibility it carries in this team and club. Would love for course correction but that's a tough one to walk back - I see him ultimately & inevitably on the exit ramp, making not one but two central defenders needed

On Garcia, some in media have spun his comments to suggest Joan isn't at Neuer's level while in fact Hansi just sidestepped comparisons considering the level of all the keepers he has coached. Yet still stated that Joan's quality was clear from Day 1 and that he is the future. I think that resonated for me as it should for all cules who watch Garcia's performances - there is supreme confidence with him in the XI and in no time he will be the most talked about gk in game

On end of match drama, clear the Sorg aspect profoundly affected him and he articulated the desire to collect himself before reacting in the dressing room. That kind of composure and introspection as a very visible coach at the biggest club in the world is admirable not to mention atypical. Always sincere, honest & unflinching and clearly the club and exposure to a new culture has had a visible impact on the coach as well. Moreover, he handles it in a manner that cules should feel proud of - different from Pep or Lucho's personality but just as extraordinary and befitting of Barça. Just wonder in this adaptation to a new culture how much of an impact the absurdity of La Liga & RFEF has had on his well being
 

serghei

Senior Member
Match vs Alaves wasn't good. He was disappointed that after a 0-3 in CL the team didn't have a more fitting response in terms of pride and mentality. There's issues in the team that are tied to Flick also, not only the players. The super advanced pressing he expects can't be central to absolutely everything.

There's some issues that can be improved by Flick also. Move the ball more and be more patient in build-up, don't expect Casado to offer similar passing quality to Pedri for example. When you have Pedri out and Casado in, you have to tweak the way you play and play more cautious. Or else you find yourself giving the ball away too much in the wrong places, which is what Casado did. That goes against Flick's football, which is build on directness and pressing. The pressing lowers the risk of his direct style. Flick is not really a possession manager at heart. Barca and German styles can be similar in places, but the Barca philosophy is also built on patience, control, and more elaborate and long passing sequences.

The relation is between the risk you take with your passing and the quality of pressing. You can take more risk when the press is better. And the risk you take with your passing depends on how good the off the ball movement is from more offensive players and obviously the individual quality of the passer. An easier pass for Pedri is not as easy for Casado.

All 3 are suffering and generate more bad turnovers that lead to even weak opponents having many clear chances vs Barca. Some players don't move well or often enough to provide passing options, the individual quality of the passer moving from Pedri to Casado took a massive hit, and the press when the ball was lost was also subpar.

You can tackle some of these things, but Flick doesn't like compromise.
 
Last edited:

Windhook

Well-known member
Yikes he threw Garcia under the bus

Q- After coaching Joan Garcia, what's the thing you're surprised most about him? And is he one of the best you've ever coached?

🚨🎙️| Flick: "This isn't an easy question, because I was the coach for both Neuer and Marc. Both of them are great keepers.
You are fake news, kid.

Flick said that, but your quote omits the praise on Joan:
From the first day I saw his quality. He has a great future ahead of him and his arrival was a great move. He will bring us security for years to come.

That's the official Barca site. If I dig into Indian fansites that milk this shit, what Hansi said is:
I coached Neuer and Marc, who are fantastic goalkeepers. Joan has a great future ahead of him. From day one, you can see his potential, and he demonstrates it in matches. He has great quality in goalkeeping and with his feet. He’s very quick. It was the right decision for the club. He gives us a lot for the coming years. He brings great security.
 
Last edited:

Barcaman

Administrator
Staff member
Curious if anyone thinks this Barca reminds them of Van Gaal's Barca. Similar gung-ho football with many young home-growns.

We were very attractive to watch with front trio Rivaldo- Kluivert- Figo breaking scoring records while defense was often source of ridicule. 2 back to back league titles but without European success.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top