Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    143

Jozh

Active member
Long-term is a different discussion.

Short-term, Flick plays with 2 at the base. Right now the best 2 to play there are Pedri and De Fraud.
That's not changing.



Not in a million years. The moment someone like him comes to Barca, fans would want him out after a game.
Bernal as DM could work, but that's for the future
Hmmm let's think about that then, Flick plays with 2 at the base, those 2 at the base cause problems... 🤔 so what do you think Flick should do

a) Stop playing with 2 at the base and change so you can compensate

b) keep playing with 2 at the base so we can keep getting screwed against teams who know what they're doing
 

Temptation

Well-known member
I might get crapped on for saying this, but I genuinely think this Chelsea side has a better overall squad than any other team this season. FFS, they were missing arguably their best player and still could slot in at least two players for him with very minimal drop in quality.

I could see them going very far in the CL this season, most likely semis. Maresca does a good job of increasing the intensity in the big ties.
Well you're wrong. Arsenal have a better squad. Liverpool and PSG have a better 11. Barca and City have a much better attack.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Hmmm let's think about that then, Flick plays with 2 at the base, those 2 at the base cause problems... 🤔 so what do you think Flick should do

a) Stop playing with 2 at the base and change so you can compensate

b) keep playing with 2 at the base so we can keep getting screwed against teams who know what they're doing

Far from 'two at base causing problems'.

By far bigger issues than that.
 

Jozh

Active member
Hmmm let's think about that then, Flick plays with 2 at the base, those 2 at the base cause problems... 🤔 so what do you think Flick should do

a) Stop playing with 2 at the base and change so you can compensate

b) keep playing with 2 at the base so we can keep getting screwed against teams who know what they're doing
God forbid you change the things that aren't working and actually tactically do something.
 

Birdy

Senior Member
Hmmm let's think about that then, Flick plays with 2 at the base, those 2 at the base cause problems... 🤔 so what do you think Flick should do

a) Stop playing with 2 at the base and change so you can compensate

b) keep playing with 2 at the base so we can keep getting screwed against teams who know what they're doing

The problem is not at the base. It's with the CBs and full-backs.
We have several like Araujo Kounde, Balde at times, who can't pass, and get trapped in the opposition's pressing
 

serghei

Senior Member
Spain play Pedri deeper in a two now.

FDJ/Pedri Olmo is Barca best midfield for taking ball in tight games.

But still the reason teams can press them like that is in large part due to how Barca lack pace particularly at CF and how poor likes o Kounde/Araujo and BAlde are when asked to make decisions to pass ball under pressure.

Chelsea were up the arse of Barca all game as no threat at all being caught out with ball in behind.

Spain setup is a bit different, I can agree with this. They have a DM in Rodri/Zubimendi, and a box to box in Fabian/Merino, Merino more attacking and Fabian with more defensive contribution. De Jong is not a real box to box, not a DM either, a difficult player to fit in. The pair De Jong and Pedri is too lightweight, easily pressable. Not robust enough for a direct style.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
The problem is not at the base. It's with the CBs and full-backs.
We have several like Araujo Kounde, Balde at times, who can't pass, and get trapped in the opposition's pressing

And lack of options out of it as Fermin doesnt have the thought to try and take game into his feet to relieve presure and there is no pace at CF or threat of early ball there.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Spain setup is a bit different. They have a DM in Rodri/Zubimendi, and a box to box in Fabian/Merino. De Jong is not a real box to box. The pair De Jong and Pedri is too lightweight, easily pressable. Not robust enough for a direct style.

Thats not how Spain have been setting up recently.

Pedri been deeper and Merino at AM to add physicality in box.

Spain also dont have to play teams of standard of those top teams in CL either.
 

Jozh

Active member
The problem is not at the base. It's with the CBs and full-backs.
We have several like Araujo Kounde, Balde at times, who can't pass, and get trapped in the opposition's pressing
You guys are literally lying to yourselves, Balde and Cubarsi is a build up cheat code and Kounde can pass a ball. The only one who struggles is Araujo.
 

ZenI

Professor Balthazar
At least as far as md and attack is concerned, he didn't have other fit players mate.
Simple as that

Now, if you wanna argue Christensen should have played instead of Araujo, I will hear that, but that's a limited discussion

PS: Chelsea show up in big games. Review all their big games under MAresca to see that
This is wrong, Olmo and Rashy should have started.
 

Birdy

Senior Member
I never said not but I was under the impression that defending was something we were discussing

Problem with defending starts from up top with attackers pressing suboptimally, and in general the team pressing with 50% or less of the last season's intensity.
This is not on PEdri and De Fraud either
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
we needed Pedri badly today. We had almost no player who wanted to take the ball from defense and bring it up.

Barca were facing same issues v PSG, Sevilla with Pedri.

Were failing to win 4 of the last 5 games he played in with a lot of same issues.

Of course Pedri improves team but those same issues still there.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top