Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    136

serghei

Senior Member
I hope fans dont want Hansi out when he wins only Copa or nothing. LL will be extremely difficult with the thin squad and the injuries. In CL a lot of luck is needed.

No. A season of no titles is accepted after a successful one normally, especially when you have a team and a squad with various and complex problems. Depends on how you end up though. If you start to get outplayed like that by all decent teams in the league...

But doubt it will get to that as I said. He will leave on his own if he feels he's out of ideas with this squad. This is not the guy to hang on to his chair no matter what.

A person with his ideas... he's the most ambitious of the lot. It's go big or go home.
 

Richard.H

Senior Member
You know I was thinking if we fail this season and Liverpool fail too, I could easily see him going there. He will have the budget and the players to play exactly the system he wants. I do not see the fans and the board taking any failure lightly of both clubs.

I could see Xavi coming back and trying to work with our limited squad and (presumably) limited budget.

This is just all worst-case scenario hypothesis. I do not want Hansi to leave, would love for him to stay at least 4 seasons and leave a lasting legacy like Pep and Lucho.
 

Barcaman

Administrator
Staff member
If he goes he will leave out of frustration with the board and how this club of this history and stature is run like a private village inn. Utter lack of professionalism and ethic on the highest levels.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
My point is neither the board or the fans will take a trophyless season lightly (if it does happen). He is not Catalan, not Spanish, not Latin. No one will take it easy on him. He has no "biases" in his favor.

After what he did last year with the football after the mess with how Xavi left, he's built up enough credit to get one season without winning.

I can't predict if he'll resign, but I would bet my house he won't get the sack unless everything completely falls apart this season in such a way that every reasonable person would say he should be fired, but I can't see that happening.
 

Don Juan Laporta Estruch

Basta yaaaaaaa, Cabron ! y Bona nit 🥂
He won't leave nor will he be sacked. Local fans are in love with him and if the team goes trophyless there will be murmurs but no clamour for him to be sacked.

He won't leave because he is in love with the club. He described last season as the best year of his life.

In real life, people are a lot more rational than internet fans who enjoy throwing their toys out of the pram at the slightest inconvenience.

Word on the ground is he is doing a fantastic job, high line or no line.
 

Givenchy

Senior Member
Yestreday game saddens not because we lost, that happens, but because we didn't, and obviously won't, learn anything. We will try and die by our style which some may think is smart but i think truly smart decision is not to be stubborn as a mule.
Our typical game, if we don't dominate, it's not we are loosing it it's save us for not getting 5 or more in our net. We refuse to suffer sometimes, grind, play deeper, weather the storm and try to win ugly from time to time. No, if our players are tired, sick, missing, whatever we will play the same game.
Actually agree with you here and I said this before many seasons ago, Barca just don't do pragmatic. Under Flick it's even more apparant and thus we are the neutrals dream to watch. We could blow a team away 7-0, it could be 5-4 madness or we get stuffed but there aren't many calm, boring games.

Winning ugly is something Madrid have down to a fine art in their CL wins and its necessary in knockout football.

I was pissed about PSG and even more fucked off about Sevilla game but at the end of the day, I wouldn't change anything about this club or Flick, it's a rollercoaster ride but it's worth watching. Barca won't change.
 

ZenI

Professor Balthazar
I'm thinking we should try a 4-3-3'ish again. Bernal and Garcia as DM's with Casado as backup - Pedri and Frenkie and Olmo as CM's (+Gavi) - Fermin as "false" 10 and Rags as central forwards (maybe try Roony there as "false" 10 also, sometimes Raphinha) - Yamal, Rashy, Raphinha and Tuna wingers.
The high line is killing us and Olmo does fuck all as 10 anyway. With a DM we could stabilize shit and still let Frenkie/Pedri/Olmo go forward a lot with the DM slotting into place. Sure play the high line, but when Flick keeps rotating the CB's and doesn't find a pair that plays together week in and week out it WILL fail. Inigo was more important than some gave him credit for, today we miss that kind of leadership in the back - Cuabrsi is young, Araujo is an idiot etc. I'd sell Ara yesterday if w could get an elite left footed CB some fucking leadership in his place.
 

ZenI

Professor Balthazar
He won't leave nor will he be sacked. Local fans are in love with him and if the team goes trophyless there will be murmurs but no clamour for him to be sacked.

He won't leave because he is in love with the club. He described last season as the best year of his life.

In real life, people are a lot more rational than internet fans who enjoy throwing their toys out of the pram at the slightest inconvenience.

Word on the ground is he is doing a fantastic job, high line or no line.
I agree 100%.
Also, he's working with he has. But I still wouldn't trust him with transfers - but I don't trust Deco either.

Flick needs a leader in central defense, preferably a left footed one (because I still believe Cubarsi will be beast for us). We need an LB who can compete with with Balde - sell Martin for a decent sum, wish him best of luck. We need an RB who can take over from Kounde - Kounde can be backup on RB and CB. We need a new 9.
That's 4 positions, 4 players - and we would also sell some like Ara and Martin. A good sporting director could find at least 1-2 hidden or unhidden gems for relatively cheap and than we would probably have to splurge on a 9. But I fucking hope it gets done next summer, at least LB, CB and 9.
 

Iniesta Ultra

Senior Member
PSG drew versus Lille at the weekend. They tried rotating the squad and it didn't work out.

Brought on the likes of Vintinha and Ruiz but didn't help.

Mbappe got the Lille goal to ad a nice little caveat.

Suggests two things
1) yes they have the luxury to rotate in Ligue1 but at this stage of the campaign it doesn't help. And side note, Lille played Europa League Thursday.

2) Our game also took a physical chunk out of them too.

PSG know the league's guaranteed for them so they're not really concerned with a draw and smart for them to conserve energy especially with their current injuries.
 

Iniesta Ultra

Senior Member
Laporta and co need to back him in the upcoming transfer windows with signing or risk seeing this team fizzle out.

Team has a great core but it’s clear there are areas that need desperate reinforcements.

Should be building the team based off of the successes of last season and not let it regress like it looks to have this season.

Should be looking at players like Olmo and Araujo as potential sales and getting Lewa’s massive wages off the books.

Rag's contract finally ends this year so no need to find a buyer.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top