Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    143

Devils

Senior Member
Seems a bit over the top to blame the squad vs teams like Sevilla though. We should beat Sevilla with Torres and Rashford instead of Yamal and Raphinha.

Rayo and Sevilla should absolutely not create so many chances against us. No way.

We should be able to control the games far better than we did. We should wonder how come both Rayo and Sevilla played their best matches this season by far vs us.

Eh, same weaknesses we see over and over again regardless of the opposition - Aruajo being a donkey, Kounde/Martin not be able to handle being pressed, Cubarsi looking out of his depth....

Saw it all last season too...

More team are catching on now + the defence looks far worse without Inigo leading it.
 
Then he became more serious: “The first half wasn’t good from us. They were very aggressive, and we had no solutions — it really wasn’t good. In the second half, I really appreciate the reaction, how we played. That was very good to see. I don’t want to talk about the two goals — I don’t need any excuses for that. We have to learn from it, but the most important thing is the reaction. I also told the team that. With this defeat, with this emotion in the dressing room, it’s important that we keep that energy, and after the international break we will fight for every title: for the Champions League, for the Copa, for the Supercopa, and of course for the league. That’s what we want. We are a good team, the players are coming back, and we remain positive.”
 

malvolio

Senior Member
He's bogged down by the squad and injuries. 2 of the goals came right at the end after we got demoralized by the misses and threw everything at it. Normally we should have won this 3-2 if we took our chances and we wouldn't have needed to play suicidal.
"Normally" was last season, when we had Raphinha and Yamal to bail us out. We played a poor game overall, but people are used to comebacks like it's the mark of a great team and don't see a problem in this way of managing matches.
Sevilla had multiple chances and were worthy winners.
I remember last season when we got outplayed in many moments but we were scoring out of nowhere and turning the game around. Flick's biggest achievement was winning something with the overrated players we have. His football is really not that great and relies too much on things clicking every time.
 

serghei

Senior Member
Players playing offside trap for opponents that are in their own half will never be unfunny. :lol: Makes us look like complete imbeciles.
 

khaled_a_d

Senior Member
I don't want him to change a lot. It's some adjustments he needs to make. I'm not saying abandon pressing and going back to pragmatic football like 2022-23.

Adjustments can be made. High line can be addressed. I have never seen another team with such a high line like Flick.

Imo he's pushing good things to the extreme, unlike other managers.

I am not trying to be argumentative for the sake of it. Again, you raise very good and fair points.

But, football fans are like the GF that always tells you that while you are great partner, you need to change X & Y in your personality, and keep insisting on it, until it makes the relationship about why you aren't changing for her. Instead of enjoining the good stuff.

Flick is who he is, he isn't going to make amendments of his coaching style. He always goes all in, he sticks to his beliefs to the core.

He has his shortcomings, and it is well pointed and documented. And the truth is, he isn't the best coach in the World, and there was a time when we were used to even better coaches.

But he is the best that we can get, that sticks to Barca number one principle: being entertaining.

He is stubborn, like plenty of great coaches, and there will come a time when we either have to make a significant changes in the team, or go in a different direction (likely more pragmatic) because as you say, it isn't sustainable.

The squad is good, probably between 4th to 7th best in the World, depending on who you ask. I think PSG, RM & Liverpool are safely better overall. Bayern & Arsenal are more complete but we have bigger difference makers, City I think is below us a bit though bigger depth again. We are ahead of the rest.

But we have the same ambitions of the top 3, which is a bit unrealistic. And he is fairly overachieving and allowing us to dream big for the most part.

Defense needs overhaul, we need at least one more difference maker in attack. We might need to sell in order to buy, but it is something we are allergic to.
 

malvolio

Senior Member
Lol, every top team has marquee players bailing them out. Take Salah's goals and assists and Liverpool don't win EPL either.
That's what I said. The difference was Raphinha and Yamal bailing us out. Otherwise we are not this football machine that everyone thinks we are. It's that our matches have way more drama, with goals on other side.
 

serghei

Senior Member
That's what I said. The difference was Raphinha and Yamal bailing us out. Otherwise we are not this football machine that everyone thinks we are. It's that our matches have way more drama, with goals on other side.

Nobody except PSG is tbh. Most are well aware we are not a great team.

I even say repeatedly winning La Liga is hard. Today just showed it again, what can happen if you are showing your poor version at a complicated ground.

You can get beaten, sometimes badly.
 

gasgas

Senior Member
Just play 4-3-3 man what's the harm in that?

When everybody is fit it would look like this

.........................Garcia
..Kounde...Eric..........Christensen....Balde
........Pedri..........Casado...........De jong
Lamine........Raphinha.....Rashford
 
Last edited:

MagIX

Senior Member
This year we’ll see how much we’re really worth. Last year, Flick did an outstanding job, exceeding even the most optimistic expectations. The financial situation is well known, the squad is what it is: we’ll see. Surely, repeating a season like last one is practically impossible.
 

gasgas

Senior Member
Casado as single pivot would get destroyed so would De jong hard pass.

Love that front line though
Consider the midfield 3 like a triple pivot of sorts, rotating positions like PSG do with Neves- Pedri and Vitinha.

I am advocating killing the #10 position and tru #9 position because we got bums in there. I think it better we shore up our midfield solidity
 

kush

Junior Member
Can't say that I'm surprised by what is happening. The year after the treble, Bayern were a disaster under flick the following year.

It's why not winning CL last year is so disappointing because it looks like Barca is not winning anything this year.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top