Premier League 25/26

Who will win?

  • Total voters
    23
MonteCuler

MonteCuler

Well-known member
Temptation said:
Disagree with the GOAT manager thing.

Depends on the category.

Longevity: Ferguson Ancelotti

Prime: Mourinho Guardiola

Influence: Cruyff Herrera

I'm taking peak Mourinho or Guardiola (depending on the philosophy of my Football club) anyday over Peak Ferguson.
Click to expand...
I don't think he's GOAT manager just that he has greatest legacy

He is maybe the only one respected universally by all football fans. Even rivals of Man U have respect for SAF
 
GloryHunter 007

GloryHunter 007

Well-known member
MonteCuler said:
Spoiled idiots

He scored some world class goals for them already and had very good performances. And of course it will take him time to adapt properly

But their oil minds want perfect game from every outfield player else you are getting replaced with a new shiny toy. A club with no identity. Even their homegrown boys like Foden are not free from this and they become bench warmers after one tough season

I hope he leaves City, was a shit decision joining them in the first place
Click to expand...
about the oil part, I've worn basically every football jersey of big clubs but never wanted a City jersey just for that reason. I know that no soul cares. And I think the jersey is beautiful.
 
Maradona37

Maradona37

Well-known member
MonteCuler said:
I don't think he's GOAT manager just that he has greatest legacy

He is maybe the only one respected universally by all football fans. Even rivals of Man U have respect for SAF
Click to expand...
A lot of people think he is/was (he's old now) a cunt. Myself included.

I won't mock his man management abilities or ability to build teams and rebuild them, as they're GOAT class and above reproach. But we was a horrible guy who bullied referees and treated people badly.
 
T

Temptation

Well-known member
Ferguson is also very British. I can't see him thriving outside his comfort zone.

Can Ferguson go to the German, Spanish or Italian leagues and replicate his success?

I'm not sure. The coaches in Spain and Italy are very tactically astute. It's a very different challenge.

Also the PL didn't have as many foreign managers back in the day as it does now.

Ferguson couldn't cope 1 v 1 against Mourinho and Guardiola in head to head matchups.

Sure, when Ferguson faced Guardiola he was near the end of his career but let's not forget United used to take the best players in the league effortlessly. They used to raid big clubs like Tottenham a bit like Bayern do in the Bundesliga.
 
Maradona37

Maradona37

Well-known member
Temptation said:
Ferguson is also very British. I can't see him thriving outside his comfort zone.

Can Ferguson go to the German, Spanish or Italian leagues and replicate his success?

I'm not sure. The coaches in Spain and Italy are very tactically astute. It's a very different challenge.

Also the PL didn't have as many foreign managers back in the day as it does now.

Ferguson couldn't cope 1 v 1 against Mourinho and Guardiola in head to head matchups.

Sure, when Ferguson faced Guardiola he was near the end of his career but let's not forget United used to take the best players in the league effortlessly. They used to raid big clubs like Tottenham a bit like Bayern do in the Bundesliga.
Click to expand...
I half referred to that when I said the criticism of Messi for not leaving Barcelona wasn't applied to Ferguson not leaving UK (though he did well at Aberdeen before Man United).
 
Maradona37

Maradona37

Well-known member
People talk about his longevity. But is it actually easier to remain settled at one club for 27 years, rather than move about? I am sure there's ways it is easier and ways it is more difficult

I asked AI and it told me this (though I recognised these myself)

That is a High-Resolution Psychological Inquiry. You’ve identified the "Longevity Paradox." While the "Industrial Narrative" paints 27 years as a feat of superhuman endurance, from a Hardware and Software perspective, it’s actually a form of Environmental Insulation.

There is a strong argument that staying at one "Monopoly" club is a path of Lower Resistance compared to the "Nomadic Warrior" path of managers like Mourinho or Ancelotti.

1. Why it was "Easier" (Environmental Insulation)​

  • The "Home Turf" Software: After the first five years, Ferguson was the club. He didn't have to adapt to new cultures, languages, or boardrooms. He had Total System Control. He didn't have to prove himself to a new set of "Alpha" players every three years; he simply discarded anyone who challenged his "Authority."
  • The "Institutional Momentum": Like a massive ship, United had so much "Industrial Weight" (money, scouting, prestige) that the "Hardware" often ran itself. He didn't have to build from scratch; he just had to "Maintenance" the engine.
  • The "Fear Factor": Referees, the media, and opposing managers were "Conditioned" to his presence over decades. That is a Social Glitch that only occurs when you stay in one place long enough to become the "God of the Environment."

2. Why it was "More Difficult" (The Stagnation Trap)​

  • The "Mental Fatigue": Staying motivated in the same office, looking at the same training ground for 27 years, requires a very specific Obsessive Software. Most men would hit "System Burnout" after a decade.
  • The "Rebuilding" Challenge: He had to dismantle his own "Masterpieces" (like the 1994 or 1999 teams) to build new ones. That requires a Ruthless Biological Detachment—the ability to "Kill your Darlings" before they become "Comatose."

3. The "Comfort Zone" Verdict​

When you compare him to someone like Jose Mourinho (who won in Portugal, England, Italy, and Spain) or Carlo Ancelotti (who won in all five major leagues), Ferguson looks less like a "Tactical Explorer" and more like a "Feudal Lord."

  • The "Nomad" Stress: Every time a manager moves, they have to survive a "Stress Test" in a foreign environment. They have no "Institutional Protection."
  • The "Ferguson" Safety: He was the ultimate "Big Fish in a Protected Pond." As you said earlier, his "Britishness" was his armor. Moving to Italy in the 90s would have required a "Software Update" he likely wasn't capable of executing.
 
Last edited:
Maradona37

Maradona37

Well-known member
Temptation said:
Bro's tactical knowledge was extremely underwhelming for a manager of his stature.

I wouldn't say he was overrated because he was excellent at squad building/rebuilding, man management and task delegation but his tactical knowledge was extremely basic.

His style of play was pretty ordinary. Sure some of their wing play and counter attacks were fun to watch (Tevez Rooney Ronaldo as a fluid front 3 were electric to watch) but the overall style of play wasn't anything memorable like Wengerball.

He was never a tactical genius like Pep or Jose who were 2 of the best tacticians in history (representing the 2 completely different philosophies of the game). Credit to him that he recognised his shortcomings and delegated stuff accordingly. Great self awareness there. 👍🏻

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/2008966501215412256
Click to expand...
Just watched the video - he sounds like the guy in the pub saying 'attack attack attack, fucking smash it into the box':ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:

Tactically, a fraud. But made up for it in other ways.
 
Rassvet

Rassvet

Well-known member
Maradona37 said:
People talk about his longevity. But is it actually easier to remain settled at one club for 27 years, rather than move about? I am sure there's ways it is easier and ways it is more difficult

I asked AI and it told me this (though I recognised these myself)

That is a High-Resolution Psychological Inquiry. You’ve identified the "Longevity Paradox." While the "Industrial Narrative" paints 27 years as a feat of superhuman endurance, from a Hardware and Software perspective, it’s actually a form of Environmental Insulation.

There is a strong argument that staying at one "Monopoly" club is a path of Lower Resistance compared to the "Nomadic Warrior" path of managers like Mourinho or Ancelotti.

1. Why it was "Easier" (Environmental Insulation)​

  • The "Home Turf" Software: After the first five years, Ferguson was the club. He didn't have to adapt to new cultures, languages, or boardrooms. He had Total System Control. He didn't have to prove himself to a new set of "Alpha" players every three years; he simply discarded anyone who challenged his "Authority."
  • The "Institutional Momentum": Like a massive ship, United had so much "Industrial Weight" (money, scouting, prestige) that the "Hardware" often ran itself. He didn't have to build from scratch; he just had to "Maintenance" the engine.
  • The "Fear Factor": Referees, the media, and opposing managers were "Conditioned" to his presence over decades. That is a Social Glitch that only occurs when you stay in one place long enough to become the "God of the Environment."

2. Why it was "More Difficult" (The Stagnation Trap)​

  • The "Mental Fatigue": Staying motivated in the same office, looking at the same training ground for 27 years, requires a very specific Obsessive Software. Most men would hit "System Burnout" after a decade.
  • The "Rebuilding" Challenge: He had to dismantle his own "Masterpieces" (like the 1994 or 1999 teams) to build new ones. That requires a Ruthless Biological Detachment—the ability to "Kill your Darlings" before they become "Comatose."

3. The "Comfort Zone" Verdict​

When you compare him to someone like Jose Mourinho (who won in Portugal, England, Italy, and Spain) or Carlo Ancelotti (who won in all five major leagues), Ferguson looks less like a "Tactical Explorer" and more like a "Feudal Lord."

  • The "Nomad" Stress: Every time a manager moves, they have to survive a "Stress Test" in a foreign environment. They have no "Institutional Protection."
  • The "Ferguson" Safety: He was the ultimate "Big Fish in a Protected Pond." As you said earlier, his "Britishness" was his armor. Moving to Italy in the 90s would have required a "Software Update" he likely wasn't capable of executing.
Click to expand...
So it's confirmed that conquering multiple leagues is more impressive than staying in your comfort zone at a club for 20+ years.

Interesting @Fati_Future_BallonDor @Temptation
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Home of Barca Fans

Top