you misunderstood me there. I rate Vidic really high, I think he's better, less injury prone, and more consistent than Rio. what I meant is that Vidic didn't have the best of nights yesterday, he made some crucial tackles at the beginning but then he started to get owned, he also should've done better for Messi's goal, and for me on average that isn't a good overall match but somehow he ended up being ManUtd second best player on the night and that reflected on how poor they were. hopefully it's clear now.