Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    136

Givenchy

Senior Member
It's not a surprising result.

Anyone with common sense knew that we needed defenders in the summer and we got nothing lol.

-Araujo - poor technically and hugely error prone.
-Christensen - can't be relied on as too injury prone
-Cubarsi - overrated as fuck by this fanbase. Nowhere near good enough and still has a lot to learn. Can't even remember the last time this guy was good.
-Garcia - should be playing at RB not CB.

Again, Inigo was the best defender at this club, what on earth were those clowns thinking when they let him go for free to Saudi without getting a replacement?

Don't even need to touch on the fullback situation lmao, it's even more worse than the CB situation.
I'd honestly try Eric at RB, Kounde CB with either Christensen or Araujo.

Inigo was the glue clearly.
 

MonteCuler

Well-known member
Bro stop with your excuses, the entire PSG front 3 was missing they had two kids start and their 4th choice Forward in barcola.

No excuses for that talking about SD, what are we even talk about.

They were also missing neves and vitinha was injured according to every single report and their captain was out.

So that's 5 players completely missing and one playing with a knock.

We were missing balde today that's basically it, rashford did well and Tek did his job, he's not saving any of those shorts nor is Garcia.

But even if you want to add raphinha, it makes no difference it's 2 to 5 and a half ffs lol, because I Garcia vs tek is a non starter

We put on a poor display today against a PSG B teams that's just the truth accept it and move on.
Barcola is not a benchwarmer at PSG. He has started many big games before and possibility is he would start this one even if all were fit.

Vitinha as far as I could see was on the pitch. I don't know about his injury. Yamal also just came back from injury and it was felt on the pitch, should we count him out?

It's a lie that Tek couldn't do anything on those shots. Neither was unstoppable. Specifically the Mayulu shot. And I shouldn't even talk about his distribution. He was just hoofing the ball all the time, not even trying to pass it to someone in Barça shirt. Constantly losing possesion like that in a game like this, it's no small thing. But he's our backup goalkeeper, so we have to live with it

Rashford did well, yes. But that doesn't mean Raphinha was not missed. Raphinha is the most direct and energetic player on the team, presses the most and is not afraid to shot. That's what we lacked today. And if we had Rashford to pull from the bench in those dying minutes instead of Lewandowski who can't run, it would probably help.

These are no excuses. We played bad and we lost. But it's unfair to picture it like "PSG had all their starters out we were full strength and still lost". The situation was completely different. Absences wise we were approximately equal in disadvantages. But for the fact PSG managed to use them better than we did, there are no excuses indeed.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Barcola is not a benchwarmer at PSG. He has started many big games before and possibility is he would start this one even if all were fit.

Vitinha as far as I could see was on the pitch. I don't know about his injury. Yamal also just came back from injury and it was felt on the pitch, should we count him out?

It's a lie that Tek couldn't do anything on those shots. Neither was unstoppable. Specifically the Mayulu shot. And I shouldn't even talk about his distribution. He was just hoofing the ball all the time, not even trying to pass it to someone in Barça shirt. Constantly losing possesion like that in a game like this, it's no small thing. But he's our backup goalkeeper, so we have to live with it

Rashford did well, yes. But that doesn't mean Raphinha was not missed. Raphinha is the most direct and energetic player on the team, presses the most and is not afraid to shot. That's what we lacked today. And if we had Rashford to pull from the bench in those dying minutes instead of Lewandowski who can't run, it would probably help.

These are no excuses. We played bad and we lost. But it's unfair to picture it like "PSG had all their starters out we were full strength and still lost". The situation was completely different. Absences wise we were approximately equal in disadvantages. But for the fact PSG managed to use them better than we did, there are no excuses indeed.

At no point did I say PSG have all their starters out, don't debate if you're going to use words to shade what I said.

The had 5 starters missing and one playing with a knock,.that's all facts.

Even if I give you our 3, that's still 2.5 an almost 100% advantage to us as it relates to injured and missing players. And we weren't missing all the starters from one section of our team like they were and playing away from home.

Yet the completely dominated us for 65 minutes.

Barcola isn't a starter for PSG anymore in big games, which a game vs Barcelona certainly is.

All of a sudden Tek is a scrub lol
 

serghei

Senior Member
Key of the game is they pressed better a worse backline than we did a better one. Having 2 wingers who think of themselves as stars made this a really bad match-up for us.

All of the PSG players gave a very good effort. Nobody had to run extra to cover for laziness. Means all of their players were fresh.

Luis Enrique benched Dembele in the early games of the past season not because he somehow lost his speed. He benched him at first because he was not giving enough effort. When pressing is the only plan you have, it better be pretty damn great.

Ours was often terrible, spotty as shite.
 
Last edited:

Porque

Senior Member
This. didnt get the Araujo snub. He's prone to the occasional brainfart or two but I felt he would have been better. Christensen is too slow.

Think Araujo would have been a disaster though next to Kounde.

If anything, perhaps the play would have been Araujo at RB for a bit more physicality and pace.

Or Eric RB with Araujo centre.

But basically our lack of pace and lack of ball playing either/or across the line couldn't counter the PSG press of 8.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top