1+9 - Lamine Yamal

Catta

Senior Member
Even though Lamine is the best, I hope Raphinha gets it for his season, he deserves it the most for his hard work, and his clutch play. After him would put Pedri, stats are not everything, if Rodri deserved it, so does Pedri.
 

Loki

Well-known member
Votes also depend on popularity. Many journalists don't like Dembele because they covered his behaviour in striking and forcing his exists from Rennes and Dortmund. Also how he left Barca didn't bring him any sympathy by leaving after the club nursed him to health for years, demanding half his release clause goes into his pocket.
If France football won't screw with the votes to let a french player win, I think either Rapha or Lamine will win it comfortably. It also depends on the Fifa WC this summer. If QSG wins it too, then Dembele will win it.

But there is also a chance that Inter will win the final and then the discussion is over anyways.
 

Kul_z

Senior Member
Dembele will win it
Not. None of the journos and club captains would vote for dumbele. Lamine is the player that tactics are already based on, at 17 he has already the attention what only messi and neymar had. Ffs liverpool squad celebrated the title in sunglasses, kid's influence is absolutely strathospheric
 

Messigician

Senior Member
Not. None of the journos and club captains would vote for dumbele. Lamine is the player that tactics are already based on, at 17 he has already the attention what only messi and neymar had. Ffs liverpool squad celebrated the title in sunglasses, kid's influence is absolutely strathospheric

Bookies disagree with you
 

TheStig

Member
Lamine is in the sweet spot for neutral fans across the world. He's amazing but still very young which people find cute and like him.

Very soon he'll get lots of haters, it happens to every successfull player/club. It happened with Messi who didn't really provoke anybody, Lamine will.
 

Kul_z

Senior Member
Lamine is in the sweet spot for neutral fans across the world. He's amazing but still very young which people find cute and like him.

Very soon he'll get lots of haters, it happens to every successfull player/club. It happened with Messi who didn't really provoke anybody, Lamine will.
Lamine would make them hate every blood cell. Cant wait for that actually
 

malvolio

Senior Member
Even though Lamine is the best, I hope Raphinha gets it for his season, he deserves it the most for his hard work, and his clutch play. After him would put Pedri, stats are not everything, if Rodri deserved it, so does Pedri.
He's a donkey though. Stats don't paint the whole picture.
 

malvolio

Senior Member
Votes also depend on popularity. Many journalists don't like Dembele because they covered his behaviour in striking and forcing his exists from Rennes and Dortmund. Also how he left Barca didn't bring him any sympathy by leaving after the club nursed him to health for years, demanding half his release clause goes into his pocket.
If France football won't screw with the votes to let a french player win, I think either Rapha or Lamine will win it comfortably. It also depends on the Fifa WC this summer. If QSG wins it too, then Dembele will win it.

But there is also a chance that Inter will win the final and then the discussion is over anyways.
They could also see it as Dembele's redemption arc.
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
Dembele wins it if PSG wins the CL.

If they don't then I think Lamine has a very good shot if he takes down France again in the Nations League which is a tinpot friendly tourney, but you never know with the voters.
 
Only reason I don't want Lamine to win it this year is that it might just be a bit too much a bit too early. Euros, la liga, world acclaim, massive new contract, all before he's 18. Add a balondor to that this year, I really don't know what that'll do to him mentally.

He may not immediately lose motivation next year, but it just feels like it might be for the best if he doesn't win it, because let's face it, he's going to win it sooner than later. The footballing meta is weak and there's nobody around that's a clear favourite.
 

serghei

Senior Member
I'm fine if Dembele wins it, but only if he has a spectacular final. To win it while Lamine had an insane semifinal, just because his team won the CL... :lol: that's fucking retarded considering he plays in a mediocre league.
 

FCBarca

Mike the Knife
We have some really spineless members posing as fans hoping one of our own players doesn’t win an award because its too soon or might go to their head :rolleyes:

Maybe football isn’t for you
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
Only reason I don't want Lamine to win it this year is that it might just be a bit too much a bit too early. Euros, la liga, world acclaim, massive new contract, all before he's 18. Add a balondor to that this year, I really don't know what that'll do to him mentally.

He may not immediately lose motivation next year, but it just feels like it might be for the best if he doesn't win it, because let's face it, he's going to win it sooner than later. The footballing meta is weak and there's nobody around that's a clear favourite.

He'll chase Messi's record of 8.
You never know obviously, but he seem to be in a good place mentally. His comments after the Inter exit and Copa/Liga trophies suggest so.

Like he said he can never get tired of winning, it's the only thing he thinks about all the time.

Winning.

That's an elite mentality to have if he keeps up with it.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top