Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    140

JamDav1982

Senior Member
So what if we were getting outplayed. It's a tough game away. Getting outplayed for portions in the match is probably expected. It's what you do under that pressure that defines the match. And the weak members of the team folded like a deck of cards.

The team lacks players than can play ball out from back and also lack pace 1v1 up top.

Both PSG and Chelsea exposed that big time and targetted it.

They both shut off balls by man marking midfield. Show ball to full backs and also Araujo.

There is no early long ball to get past it either or player at AM that can take it to feet and get game up park.
 

JohnN

Senior Member
choosing araujo is by default a mistake and I am pretty sure he won't make it again. its not like we are stacked with great defenders either.
 

Jozh

Active member
At least as far as md and attack is concerned, he didn't have other fit players mate.
Simple as that

Now, if you wanna argue Christensen should have played instead of Araujo, I will hear that, but that's a limited discussion

PS: Chelsea show up in big games. Review all their big games under MAresca to see that
First of all, these issues have been here even with Pedri this season. Even buildup, especially on that damned left side. Second of all, Pedri and DeJong are terrible off the ball and I seriously think the long term future is with one of them out of it. This season to me they contribute to our inability to actually defend well as a team.
 

serghei

Senior Member
The team lacks players than can play ball out from back and also lack pace 1v1 up top.

Both PSG and Chelsea exposed that big time and targetted it.

They both shut off balls by man marking midfield. Show ball to full backs and also Araujo.

There is no early long ball to get past it either or player at AM that can take it to feet and get game up park.

We lack several things. A strong midfielder is another. Raphinha is gonna be different compared to a physically weak player like Torres.

Olmo was a terrible transfer for us.

If you think any player out of Pedri, Fermin, Olmo, Frenkie are anywhere near as physical as Caicedo - Enzo duo for example, that would be hilarious.
 

serghei

Senior Member
Even with Pedri Chelsea would have done the same.

Man marked him and FDJ and show ball to fullbacks/Araujo.

And most likely would have caused a lot of same problems.

That's when the 3rd midfielder comes into play. You know my theory that Pedri should not be a deep build up player to begin with whenever heavy press is involved.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
We lack several things. A strong midfielder is another. Raphinha is gonna be different compared to a physically weak player like Torres.

Olmo was a terrible transfer for us.

If you think any player out of Pedri, Fermin, Olmo, Frenkie are anywhere near as physical as Caicedo - Enzo duo for example, that would be hilarious.

Caicedo and Enzo didnt play as a duo.

Enzo was more or less a striker for most of game today and he when plays deeper can get run off a lot.
 

serghei

Senior Member
What should happen is a DM should get signed, paired with De Jong, and Pedri moved up. Similar to how Spain play it.

That doesn't fix all issues, but it improves the situation.

People exaggerate a bit with the praise to both De Jong and Pedri. They are technical players, but they both have some phsycal limitations that are evident at this level. You fix this to a degree by adding a midfielder of outstanding physical pressence.
 

Birdy

Senior Member
Why doesn't anyone who whines on Flick notes that until the red, we had several correct combinations that broke their pressing, and released Balde in space (the left half space) with 3vs 3 or 4 vs 4 situations for us?

Of course, it didn't always work because we had an imbecile in Ferran trying to make correct one time passes
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
What should happen is a DM should get signed, paired with De Jong, and Pedri moved up. Similar to how Spain play it.

Spain play Pedri deeper in a two now.

FDJ/Pedri Olmo is Barca best midfield for taking ball in tight games.

But still the reason teams can press them like that is in large part due to how Barca lack pace particularly at CF and how poor likes o Kounde/Araujo and BAlde are when asked to make decisions to pass ball under pressure.

Chelsea were up the arse of Barca all game as no threat at all being caught out with ball in behind.
 

jairzinho

Senior Member
What should happen is a DM should get signed, paired with De Jong, and Pedri moved up. Similar to how Spain play it.

That doesn't fix all issues, but it improves the situation.

People exaggerate a bit with the praise to both De Jong and Pedri.

This. We could use a Palinha type player to add some variation to our midfield.
 

Birdy

Senior Member
First of all, these issues have been here even with Pedri this season. Even buildup, especially on that damned left side. Second of all, Pedri and DeJong are terrible off the ball and I seriously think the long term future is with one of them out of it. This season to me they contribute to our inability to actually defend well as a team.

Long-term is a different discussion.

Short-term, Flick plays with 2 at the base. Right now the best 2 to play there are Pedri and De Fraud.
That's not changing.

This. We could use a Palinha type player to add some variation to our midfield.

Not in a million years. The moment someone like him comes to Barca, fans would want him out after a game.
Bernal as DM could work, but that's for the future
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Why doesn't anyone who whines on Flick notes that until the red, we had several correct combinations that broke their pressing, and released Balde in space (the left half space) with 3vs 3 or 4 vs 4 situations for us?

Of course, it didn't always work because we had an imbecile in Ferran trying to make correct one time passes

Ferran and Fermin fucked up multiple times that Balde and Frenkie broke game open in first half.

Balde can do it on the dribble.. ask him to pass ball and its a hard watch.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top