Some thoughts:
- Getting the league won so early, having the 'benefit' of resting the entire first 11 the game before this match is not a benefit at all if the manager doesn't ensure his players use this physical advantage by pressing and running during the game. It is not a benefit either if, as a result of the rest, the players arrive for this match looking sluggish and off-tempo with their game. I feared this would happen, the players looked like they were in holiday mode.
- The approach to the game put Barca on the back foot from the first whistle - Valverde opting for a half-way defensive approach with a (shocking) defensive midfield of Vidal, Busi and Raki but an attacking trident of Suarez, Messi and Countinho. There was a disconnect here literally on the pitch and mentally too. Were we trying to defend or get a goal? I don't think the players knew.
- Valverde approached the game like Liverpool had the advantage, in terms of tactics and the mentality of the players, despite what should be an almost unassailable 3-0 lead and the confidence that should breed. The approach should have been the opposite; we have a 3-0 lead and we will kill this game with 1 goal if you attack too openly. Liverpool should have been forced to worry about not conceding that game-killing away goal but Barca only started playing this way from 80 minutes, which was the only time Barca made Liverpool suffer. Absolute failure.
- Valverde does not have the leadership, tactical knowledge or experience to manage at this level. That is absolutely clear. He does not have the leadership as you can see there is no vision or philosophy that he has instilled on these players. He's like a guy standing in the corner trying to not get in their way, that's his small-time mentality as he is a nobody (I had never heard of him until couple years ago) that has not won anything before arriving at Barca. Tactical knowledge is completely absent as was plain to see over these two legs and last year against Roma. Nothing clever or suprising about his approach, rather the opposite.
- You can criticise the players all day long but the fact is they have won nearly everything in the game, so this slack attitude is endemic in the team at this point. Therefore we need a manager that they can respect and listen to, someone who can motivate them. This little dwarf with the big nose with his quiet voice and lack of passion is not the man to do it. Certainly not now, if they had a small amount of belief in him before, it has all but vanished now. Bartomeu most come to this conclusion.
- That said some players clearly do not meet the Barca standard. Standards have fallen. Vidal is not and will never be a Barca player. Why he was purchased was strange, that he is a starting player now in big games an even bigger mystery and betrayal of Barca's DNA and Cruyff's philosophy. Yes he showed some fight but Barca is more than just 'fight'. Countinho they paid double what he is worth and he should have never been signed. He lacks technical qualities (he is too trained in 100mph heavy metal Liverpool football to adjust to Spanish football) and has a small-time mentality and confidence. Again, not the standard of player we need. Raki and Busi are old now and need to be rotated with fresh blood (De Jong for one) next season.