bismp
Well-known member
Disclaimer:This poll by no means aims to divide the fanbase.If the mods think that it does they may delete it,i won't say anything about it.
So,Neymar vs Suarez.Obviously both of them have had a fantastic season and i am sure that they will perform well at the few remaining matches,but ofc both of them are at least a level worse than Leo.Before doing any comparison,we have to aknowledge that this was Ney's 2nd season,while it was the first for Suarez.In the meanwhile,Luis is far more experienced,while this was only the second season of Ney in Europe.So,i believe that these 2 facts beat one another,which means that the two of them had the same potential for this season.So:
Scoring
Obviously,the most important aspect that the 2 of them must be compared to is scoring.
Ney scored more goals than Luis,but given that Luis was absent for many games because of his ban,we must assume that they have scored more or less the same amount of goals.But what is the number of goals if you score 5 against Granada?Both Ney and Luis scored MANY extremely crucial goals this season,against tough opponents.In fact,they surpass Messi in the amount of crucial goals.Luis scored multiple goals against Real,Atletico,MC,Valencia and PSG,while Ney scored in almost every important game of the season
SG,Real,Sevilla,Bayern,Atletico etc.Finally,we must admit that Luis scores more beatiful goals most of the time.
So,i believe that it is really tough,but the final verdict for this category is Neymar,due to the greatest amount of goals in general and crucial goals
Creating
It is safe to say that Messi is miles ahead from both of them in this category.In fact,both of them haven't reached the Barca level of creating yet(IMO).Having said that,even a blind man can see that Luis is just better.He has assisted far more goals,he passes the ball better etc.There isn't anything to say here: Suarez
Dribbling
I think that both of them haven't showed us their true dribbling ability yet.Neymar has a lot more potential at this category.Many times this season he has dribbled 3-4 players.The thing is that he doesn't know when to stop,which results in him losing the ball.On the other hand,Suarez is worse at dribbling (IMO) but he is more efficient.So,in conclusion Ney is theoretically better,but Luis is better in practise.It is a close call,but Suarez
Defending and attitude
I won't give any points for this category,but i have to mention some things.Both players defend decently as far as i am concerned,so i don't have to say anything more about it.As for the attitude,both of them have some bad traits(being diving for Suarez and getting into fights for Ney)but overral,both of them are responsible for the excellent team climate
CONCLUSION
It is a really close call.As i said previously,BOTH of them have had an ABSOLUTELY GREAT season,forming the msn.But taking my analysis into consideration,even though my heart says Neymar,my mind says
So,Neymar vs Suarez.Obviously both of them have had a fantastic season and i am sure that they will perform well at the few remaining matches,but ofc both of them are at least a level worse than Leo.Before doing any comparison,we have to aknowledge that this was Ney's 2nd season,while it was the first for Suarez.In the meanwhile,Luis is far more experienced,while this was only the second season of Ney in Europe.So,i believe that these 2 facts beat one another,which means that the two of them had the same potential for this season.So:
Scoring
Obviously,the most important aspect that the 2 of them must be compared to is scoring.
Ney scored more goals than Luis,but given that Luis was absent for many games because of his ban,we must assume that they have scored more or less the same amount of goals.But what is the number of goals if you score 5 against Granada?Both Ney and Luis scored MANY extremely crucial goals this season,against tough opponents.In fact,they surpass Messi in the amount of crucial goals.Luis scored multiple goals against Real,Atletico,MC,Valencia and PSG,while Ney scored in almost every important game of the season
SG,Real,Sevilla,Bayern,Atletico etc.Finally,we must admit that Luis scores more beatiful goals most of the time.So,i believe that it is really tough,but the final verdict for this category is Neymar,due to the greatest amount of goals in general and crucial goals
Creating
It is safe to say that Messi is miles ahead from both of them in this category.In fact,both of them haven't reached the Barca level of creating yet(IMO).Having said that,even a blind man can see that Luis is just better.He has assisted far more goals,he passes the ball better etc.There isn't anything to say here: Suarez
Dribbling
I think that both of them haven't showed us their true dribbling ability yet.Neymar has a lot more potential at this category.Many times this season he has dribbled 3-4 players.The thing is that he doesn't know when to stop,which results in him losing the ball.On the other hand,Suarez is worse at dribbling (IMO) but he is more efficient.So,in conclusion Ney is theoretically better,but Luis is better in practise.It is a close call,but Suarez
Defending and attitude
I won't give any points for this category,but i have to mention some things.Both players defend decently as far as i am concerned,so i don't have to say anything more about it.As for the attitude,both of them have some bad traits(being diving for Suarez and getting into fights for Ney)but overral,both of them are responsible for the excellent team climate
CONCLUSION
It is a really close call.As i said previously,BOTH of them have had an ABSOLUTELY GREAT season,forming the msn.But taking my analysis into consideration,even though my heart says Neymar,my mind says
Last edited:
