Kylian Muppet
- Thread starter Xavinho
- Start date
GloryHunter 007
Well-known member
Do you think hes #1 rn?
Horatio
You're welcome
In current form? No. I do think he has heighest ceiling of all players.
But looking at form at least Lamine is outperforming him.
ToranagaSama
Well-known member
"Would cook under Flick."
What would he cook? Fermented Swedish herring?
Entire Flick system falls apart with this type of player upfront.
What would he cook? Fermented Swedish herring?
Entire Flick system falls apart with this type of player upfront.
Temptation
Well-known member
In terms of overall impact, buildup play and actually watching games, neither Mbappe nor Yamal have been amongst the 5 best players in Europe. Infact Yamal hasn't been the best player in Barca.
Yamal is playing like a moments player too. He has been invisible for large parts of many games and then popped up with a good bit of play. Quit pretending that he's continuously influencing games like 1986 Maradona. He isn't doing that in most of the games.
The likes of Olise and Pedri have been the best this season at doing what you're claiming Yamal does. Many proper Barca fans (not people you call "trolls") here have been very critical of Yamal's overall performances this season.
MonteCuler
Well-known member
Which solo goals brother? Best I can remember is in the Bilbao game and it was a great goal but absolutely nothing like the ones Messi used to score. Other than that mostly pens or easy goals. To add to this that he doesn't press, he is selfish and disappeared in every big game bar El Clasicos (where he has loads of space against one of worst defenses you can find) this and last season.
He is not the best footballer in the world. He is very good but just no. Second to Yamal and it's not particuraly close.
MonteCuler
Well-known member
Flick would never want such an ego player in his team
Temptation
Well-known member
Yamal isn't even the best player at Barca or the best RW in the world this season.
Pedri and Olise exist.
Are you just completely ignoring Pedri during Barca games?
Horatio
You're welcome
@GloryHunter 007
Also Mbappe has this kind of bias where in peoples mind he’s “not expected to do it” so he is not marked down on it.
For example crosses. It’s fine that he doesn’t offer it as he plays 9. But he never did. So when Lamine and Mbappe comparison happens, they will want to omit looking at overall playmaking skills and technique.
I will say Lamine right now is lacking in shot.
But then again…not sure how great mbappes conversion rate is. But mbappe can put more power behind the shot definitely. Overall he has better shooting technique.
Lamine much better dribbler than Mbappe. But Mbappe has the better burst.
Also Mbappe has this kind of bias where in peoples mind he’s “not expected to do it” so he is not marked down on it.
For example crosses. It’s fine that he doesn’t offer it as he plays 9. But he never did. So when Lamine and Mbappe comparison happens, they will want to omit looking at overall playmaking skills and technique.
I will say Lamine right now is lacking in shot.
But then again…not sure how great mbappes conversion rate is. But mbappe can put more power behind the shot definitely. Overall he has better shooting technique.
Lamine much better dribbler than Mbappe. But Mbappe has the better burst.
MonteCuler
Well-known member
Olise similar to Mbappe did nothing in big games in these 1.5 years at BayernYamal isn't even the best player at Barca or the best RW in the world this season.
Pedri and Olise exist.
Plays in a weaker league and passing, creativity, dribbling wise nowhere near Yamal
Great players but you are pushing them for no reason. Mbappe and especially Olise are not Yamal level at all
Pedri has been good but also not our best player this season. Had his fair share of shit games just like Yamal. Been injured for a while too
Temptation
Well-known member
Moving goalposts now
So Yamal has had his fair share of shit games but you're just ignoring that while concentrating on every shit game other players have had?
Could you name the games where Pedri was shit? Because every time I have watched Barca he has been atleast decent.
Olise has a higher average rating and better statistics than Yamal this season. Pedri, Kane and Vitinha have better involvement and influence on games this season. Have you seen Kane's passing range? Mbappe has been way more decisive. Yamal doesn't top any metric this season. How's he the best player in the world then? Because of PR hype?
Horatio
You're welcome
Booooom called it.Moving goalposts now
So Yamal has had his fair share of shit games but you're just ignoring that while concentrating on every shit game other players have had?
Could you name the games where Pedri was shit? Because every time I have watched Barca he has been atleast decent.
Olise has a higher average rating and better statistics than Yamal this season. Pedri, Kane and Vitinha have better involvement and influence on games this season. Have you seen Kane's passing range? Mbappe has been way more decisive. Yamal doesn't top any metric this season. How's he the best player in the world then? Because of PR hype?
View attachment 14925
At least Lamine ahead of Mbappe.
Horatio
You're welcome
Horatio
You're welcome
What pr hype? lol.
A lot of things lamine does people aint even aware.
In most minds highly talented kid who plays wings and scores goals and is very fast(which they are likely overshooting) and is very arrogant.
Most are not aware he defends playmakes, is a teamplayer(unselfish) rarely gets a card or in a scuffe and would be way more productive than mbappe if given more penalties.
Temptation
Well-known member
Raphinha was injured for a while and recently been poor in games even when he has scored. Works very hard though.
Look at the Raphinha thread. Has had some poor performances lately. Not in the best form currently.
Home of Barca Fans
