Between Messi and Pep, Messi clearly has the greater credit for Barca's 08-12 run.
Because he's proven himself with multiple 50 goal seasons after Pep left and has a treble.
Meanwhile Pep has been getting dunked on in Europe at City and even at Bayern (v RM, Barca).
I think everyone agrees with this notion, no?
You started to change views.
I see that Te Amo Barca also liked a joke on the other topic how Pep will have 1/8, 1/4, 1/4 and 1/8 of a CL in his last 4 years.
So, some fans are lowering their views about Pep's magic.
Of course that he was important and that he had magic.
But his impact can work only to a some extent.
Of course, he took a team from Rijkaard and made things which Rijkaard couldn't.
But still, compared to a post-Pep's era, Pep had the best team in the last 10 years.
Messi was young and without trophies.
Iniesta was on his prime and without trophies.
Xavi was still on his prime.
Pep will probably have 7 out 7 CL exits this season, without Messi.
Ok, you need some luck, but if a coach is that important and that magical, Pep would have surely found a way to win at least 1 title in 7 years.
Especially since he had CL winning team Bayern from 2013 and finalists from 2012 (whom he turned into a CL losers with zero CL finals) and City who is among the richest teams in the world (without a single CL semis with him).
If his system is that magical, there is no way that he would be losing in a CL over and over in an almost spectacular fashion.
Of course, you need an awesome coach.
But as Pep has showed: a good coach without truly magical gamechanger players like Messi (or Xavi-Iniesta) can improve a team only up to a certain extent.
And that line which I hate "if executed properly, nothing can beat Pep's system" also applies ONLY:
If you mix:
1. Pep
2. Messi
3. Xavi-Iniesta
4. hungry players
5. teams surprised by your system and who don't know yet how to defend
6. some luck in a CL draws to avoid our kryptonites like Milan, Juve or other physical or crazy running teams
If you can mix those 6 in the same time and in the same place, then I agree: if executed properly, nothing can beat Pep's system.
But in a real world, those 6 will never repeat in the same time, so: it is what it is. This is why Pep is losing over and over inspite of having his system.