Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    146

Temptation

Well-known member
Jamrock is right about the result being positive. I said this too.

With the away goals rule gone, this result basically makes the first leg completely and utterly irrelevant.

It's basically a one legged tie now at Camp Nou which Barca should comfortably win.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Players are not mentally ands physically drained.

It is an excuse.

Newcastle players got a day less rest and played Man Utd with 10 men for large spells, played City and rotated less.

Less rest, better opposition and less rotation.

If Barca players are drained from that game v Atletico it is more of a worry.

They lacked quality last night against a poorer Newcastle team out of form and missing most of best playes from starting line up.

Lets not count Barca win away in Bilbao.. 'as dont win bar that Yamal screamer'.

Makes no sense.

Result in isolation is ok but got away with one and performance was terrible.

Genuinely looked like Newcastle v lower league team in cup. The most dominant they have been in weeks v anyone.
 

serghei

Senior Member
OK, so team is fresh, not exhausted and drained physically, squad is much better than Newcastle, and we played like shit and Newcastle dominated us like they dominated a Championship side.

The reason then is crap management surely, so this is on Flick for you? He's the reason the team is doing much worse in big games this year?
 
Biggest problems atm are Raphi and Ferran/Lewy. 2 out of 3 offense players dont perform currently and with this high line we need players to create and score. Rashy is also sleeping too much during a game.

Maybe we should try Lamine in the middle again, Rooney on RW so Raphi,Lewy,Lamine playing closer together
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
OK, so team is fresh, not exhausted and drained physically, squad is much better than Newcastle, and we played like shit and Newcastle dominated us like they dominated a Championship side.

The reason then is crap management surely, so this is on Flick for you? He's the reason the team is doing much worse in big games this year?

No.. no team are 'fresh' at this point in season and it is excuses to make out have it tougher than others.

Yes Newcastle played that game as if it was v lower league team in cup and easiest game they have had in weeks.
 

serghei

Senior Member
Aye, the problem is Raphinha. That's why when he missed the Atletico game we beat them 4-0. Oh, wait, it was the other way around. Please...
 

serghei

Senior Member
No.. no team are 'fresh' at this point in season and it is excuses to make out have it tougher than others.

Yes Newcastle played that game as if it was v lower league team in cup and easiest game they have had in weeks.

So, shite management it is then no? Back to Xavi template 2 years ago. Good squad, poor performances in big games, and excuses served for it no?

You returned to home base. :lol:
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Biggest problems atm are Raphi and Ferran/Lewy. 2 out of 3 offense players dont perform currently and with this high line we need players to create and score. Rashy is also sleeping too much during a game.

Maybe we should try Lamine in the middle again, Rooney on RW so Raphi,Lewy,Lamine playing closer together

Said same yetserday.. would have taken Yamal off wing.

Hall was getting better of him and too much left to wait on ball in game Barca cant take control of.

Raph could have gone RW even and told to try and limit Hall more than anything as he was coasting on ball.

Olmo at AM and closer to Pedri/Bernal also to help them as were being physically out matched too often and looked slow.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
So, shite management it is then no? Back to Xavi template 2 years ago. Good squad, poor performances in big games, and excuses served for it no?

You returned to home base. :lol:

What are you even trying to say?

If I think Flick could have done things differently say it... and have on this game.

On players and coach when play like yesterday.
 

serghei

Senior Member
What are you even trying to say?

That nothing has changed. You were oblivious to squad issues 2 years ago, and you're still pretending this is not true despite all the evidence in the world to support it.

You don't have to be Einstein to figure the issue out. Short squad -> overplaying of main players -> long term fatigue in next season -> more injuries -> more dependent on depth -> more issues because depth is shite -> more shite performances -> more losses -> ... potentially a trashing looming, thankfully Bayern is not in our side.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
That nothing has changed. You were oblivious to squad issues 2 years ago, and you're still pretending this is not true despite all the evidence in the world to support it.

Lies... you claimed Barca 'couldnt win for years' and were wrong.

'Oblivious to squad issues' based on what?
 

serghei

Senior Member
Lies... you claimed Barca 'couldnt win for years' and were wrong.

'Oblivious to squad issues' based on what?

No lies anything. I just told you Raphinha played almost 18-20 games more than equivalent top level wingers playing for EPL top sides. It's a fact you conveniently ignore.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
That would be the Barca squad 2 years ago you claimed cant ever possibly beat Real and 'years and hundreds of millions away'.

While likes of Pedri is massively over rated.

Top stuff.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top