Verratti or Pogba?

I

instinct

Guest

• Feb 18, 2015

• #1

We are linked with several players but above all we need a RB and a CM.
Sport reported that we want to sign Verratti or Pogba in 2016.

If you had the chance to sign either Verratti or Pogba for a similar price, who would you chose? And why?

Edit: forgot to add the pole Can a mod please do it?

 

KingMessi

SiempreBlaugrana

• Feb 18, 2015

• #2

instinct said:

If you had the chance to sign either Verratti or Pogba for a similar price, who would you chose? And why?

Click to expand...

By this do you mean that, in this hypothetical situation, a deal for both has been agreed, and now we just have to pick one? Or do we still have to deal with the club first?

If the former, then Veratti. If the latter, then Pogba.

 

Ghosting

New member

• Feb 18, 2015

• #3

Not seen a lot of Pogba, is he very creative? I know he scores some amazing goals every now and then, but I thought he played quite deep, we need a CM who can create 10-15 goals a year, can't just rely on Messi for everything.

 

KingMessi

SiempreBlaugrana

• Feb 18, 2015

• #4

I'd rather have Koke than either.

 

P

pacp_96

Chief Of Footballing Matters

• Feb 18, 2015

• #5

And what would we have paid for them. Should we go on the basis of them costing the same amount?

 

I

instinct

Guest

• Feb 18, 2015

• #6

pacp_96 said:

And what would we have paid for them. Should we go on the basis of them costing the same amount?

Click to expand...

Yes

 

KingMessi

SiempreBlaugrana

• Feb 18, 2015

• #7

pacp_96 said:

And what would we have paid for them. Should we go on the basis of them costing the same amount?

Click to expand...

For the sake of holding all variables, except the player themselves, constant. Let's say 65M euro deal with both Juventus and PSG has been reached.

 

Sumlit

San Claudio Bravo

• Feb 18, 2015

• #8

This is a tough decision. I like Verratti a great deal, but €65m for Pogba is a good transfer as well.

I'll go with Verratti purely out of personal preference.

 

P

pacp_96

Chief Of Footballing Matters

• Feb 18, 2015

• #9

hmmmm. That's a really hard one.

I'd probably go with Pogba. Purely because he seems to be a more physical player than Veratti. Yes I know we have won things with midgets not to long ago but I think we need a more direct and powerful midfield with this new Barca.

 

J

JamDav1982

Senior Member

• Feb 18, 2015

• #10

No doubt Verratti is the better player on the ball but Pogba brings more strength, height and athleticism which Barca almost always lack.

I vote Pogba!!!

 

Alen

New member

• Feb 18, 2015

• #11

Verratti. Pogba is lazy.

 

KingMessi

SiempreBlaugrana

• Feb 18, 2015

• #12

To make this more interesting, can we do Koke vs. Veratti vs. Pogba? I think Koke's buyout is also 65M euros.

 

Sumlit

San Claudio Bravo

• Feb 18, 2015

• #13

KingMessi said:

To make this more interesting, can we do Koke vs. Veratti vs. Pogba? I think Koke's buyout is also 65M euros.

Click to expand...

I'd still chose Verratti, personally.

For me

Verratti, then Koke, then Pogba. All close though, can't go wrong with any of them truly.

 

Alarcón

New member

• Feb 18, 2015

• #14

KingMessi said:

To make this more interesting, can we do Koke vs. Veratti vs. Pogba? I think Koke's buyout is also 65M euros.

Click to expand...

There is no contest between Koke and these 2, he's overrated and 65m is way too much for him

 

Sumlit

San Claudio Bravo

• Feb 18, 2015

• #15

Alarcón said:

There is no contest between Koke and these 2, he's overrated and 65m is way too much for him

Click to expand...

Really don't agree with that. Koke is not overrated.

65M for a talented young midfielder to give you 7+ years of quality play, that's not outrageous.