Barca Transfers and Rumors

Let me mention things which are very obvious yet many in this forum aren't aware of


1. The board and the scouting department should take the 100% blame.

The board for drifting away from the Total Football Philosophy and making the club as a business organization and disrespecting Cruyff.

The scouting department for spending the whole year sleeping only to look clueless at the last month of the transfer. Like [MENTION=19793]Jombi[/MENTION] always use to say, it is not always wise to expect us to buy starting players from the big clubs. We should have scouted and bought the likes of Asensio, Kovacic, Veratti before they have been bought by other big clubs. We had the best midfield in the history of football. Now, we are here with the likes of Rakitic.

2. Rakitic is never a world class player. And more important than that is signing him and Suarez (and even Neymar because of his stardom status, as Cruyff mentioned) means we are drifting away more from the midfield control oriented football. And apart from that, it is Suarez who should have received the amount of criticism which Neymar received. But he escaped because of some random goals which he score more often than not.

3. We still have 5 World Class starting Players in the team

Messi, Busquets, Umtiti, Pique, Ter Stegen.

In Addition to that we also have Iniesta who can be the best midfielder in the world even now if the coach take the defensive burden off him and make him to link up with Messi more often.

4. It seems more and more apparent for me that JamDav is either a board member or someone close to the board members.

5. Because of the 5 or 6 World Class players I mentioned we can still dominate the world with an efficient Midfield oriented system and few good signings and likes of Alena (and to some extent Roberto). We have lost Veratti does not mean there is no controller out there. There are players like Seri which the board should have signed within the first few days of the transfer.

6. People are so quick to change their opinion. Gomez still appears to me as a player of very high potential. But I will not expect him to shine in a system which doesn't utilize the capacity of Busquets and Iniesta properly. And in my opinion the players we need are just three i) Seri ii)Coutinho iii)Dybala. I have not seen much of Dembele, so cannot suggest him. But I have seen few posts in these forum after Juventus destroyed us that if Dybala failed to scored in the cl final, people here in the forum would conclude that he is the most overrated player in the world. It was posted because the many users had already concluded that he is the future ballon d'or after the match against us. The reality is that he is the closest thing to Messi in the football world at the moment. But he cannot show his potential at Juventus. Coutinho, Dybala upfront with Messi as CF and with a midfield of Iniesta, Seri and Busquets should be the starting line up in my opinion. If Suarez had to be played, then you might have three men defense with four persons in midfield including Messi.

7. Barca fans should stop their obsession with Mbappe. He is the most overrated thing after Ronaldo.

8. Ballon d'or is a joke. It is never about the best player in the world. It is just about the most famous player in the best team of the world. For the good of football the award should be stopped.
 

Hektor

New member
That classic was a Messi, Ter Stegen show'

the rest were average

No man. This is a team game. One or two players by themselves will never win a game. They need the others.

I'm not saying that we did not need reinforcements to replace Neymar or replace other players with new blood. However, we could never aged this much or became this bad in two months.

Our performance this last two games was pathetic. All players looked lost not knowing what to do. They also looked dispirited. This is coaching or lack of it.
 

Thiago10

New member
We absolutely need both Dembele (to replace Neymar) and Coutinho (for some creativity in the MF), but sadly, just getting those 2 wouldn't even be enough to compete with RM. We also need some kind of maestro in the midfield that can control the play. Verratti would have been the obvious choice, but since he's not coming, we could use Seri or even Jorginho who impressed me against Nice yesterday. Neither of them would be too expensive. It's a shame our board sucks.
 

Judoman

Senior Member
I was thinking the following. Two months ago we defeated RM, in the Santiago Bernabeu, 3-2 without Neymar. Two months later we became too old, too slow, and this bad. The main difference, between now and then, is more than obvious. Two months ago Luis Enrique was at the helm; today, it is Valverde. We have the same players, but a different coach. IMHO, the solution is also more than obvious. This board has to go and take Valverde with them.

This just doesn t make sence. After 2, essencialy pre-season matches there is no need for panic mode and especialy blaming coach. In USA the team didn t look bad. Infact, we won all matches there.
Than, Neymar happened. Of course this had a huge impact on the team and it will take some time to recover, but it is not Valverde s fault, that the club is in the current state.

Board should resign. Before that they should buy what we need and sell what we don t need. Since they have 2 weeks left to do that, im not that optimistic.
 

Hektor

New member
sack Valverde, bring back Lucho

We had at least two months to look for a Lucho replacement and we settled on Valverde :banghead: I have no idea who to bring, but Valverde is not the one. People, Pep or Lucho are not a realistic alternatives. Maybe Pelegrini? I just do not know who is available at this time.

IMHO, the loss of Tito Vilanova was devastating for us. He was the genius behind Pep.
 

Hektor

New member
This just doesn t make sence. After 2, essencialy pre-season matches there is no need for panic mode and especialy blaming coach. In USA the team didn t look bad. Infact, we won all matches there.
Than, Neymar happened. Of course this had a huge impact on the team and it will take some time to recover, but it is not Valverde s fault, that the club is in the current state.

Board should resign. Before that they should buy what we need and sell what we don t need. Since they have 2 weeks left to do that, im not that optimistic.

You know that in the US, you do not fire the players all at once; you fire the manager.
 

Messi983

Senior Member
At least Pep would have sent Paulinho back to China where he belongs.

Would he really? Don't forget he was responsible for signing Chygrinskiy, Hleb, Fabregas...

He was and still is a great manager but his transfer history with us was all but great. It's very questionable if he'd really won what he has without our golden generation. His time at Bayern where he wasn't able to win CL proved that. We'll see what he'll do with City this season after spending half billion on new players since he take over.

I have a lot of respect for Pep's history with us (but I consider him as an opponent now) but I think people are wrong if they expect he could just walk back here (if he'd want that which he obviously doesn't) and make us great again without the right players for his system.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top