Thiago Silva

Brombi

New member
Why no Marquinhos?

Press release Thiago Silva (PSG): "It's not true I will travel earlier to Paris to talk about a transfer. I will fulfil my contract."

This is why:

"@O_Hal1t
All though #Barca feels required to buy #Marquinhos, a deal between #Roma and #PSG is very close. Some say within 24 hours. Need a #miracle"
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
If we had even half decent scouts we could unearth a lesser known player who would be perfect for us.

What are Marquinhos strengths and weaknesses? I thought he's almost certain to join psg anyway?

Thats not the way it works though how many clubs consistently do that?
 

Tomchin

New member
So no Thiago Silva,no Marquinhos. Who can we realistically get that would solve our defensive problems?
Agger maybe? David Luiz won't solve our defensive issues (on the contrary, his lapses together with those of Pique are a recipe for disaster), so Agger seems like the only feasible option left?
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
So no Thiago Silva,no Marquinhos. Who can we realistically get that would solve our defensive problems?

To solve our defensive problems?

No one.

We'll get stuck with a medicore CB like David Luiz who along with Pique will actually make our defence look worse.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Agger maybe? David Luiz won't solve our defensive issues (on the contrary, his lapses together with those of Pique are a recipe for disaster), so Agger seems like the only feasible option left?

Agger is just another Pique, Masch, Luiz who are not pure defenders and prefer to be stepping out of defence both with and without the ball.

Would prefer Luiz to Agger if that was the choice.
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
Agger maybe? David Luiz won't solve our defensive issues (on the contrary, his lapses together with those of Pique are a recipe for disaster), so Agger seems like the only feasible option left?

With Carra retired, Agger seem like a very unrealistic target TBH.

Maybe Konscielny is an option, but even he wants to stay at the Emirates.
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
Agger is just another Pique, Masch, Luiz who are not pure defenders and prefer to be stepping out of defence both with and without the ball.

Would prefer Luiz to Agger if that was the choice.

Agger is actually a CB contrary to Luiz and a very good one too!(And I've watched him play MANY, MANY times)

Luiz is not a CB. He is horrible at that position and even worse than Pique at times.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Agger is actually a CB contrary to Luiz and a very good one too!(And I've watched him play MANY, MANY times)

Luiz is not a CB. He is horrible at that position and even worse than Pique at times.

I have watched them both many times also ans Agger likes to come out of defence with the ball and is not a pure defender/leader type that is needed.

Personally prefer Luiz as a defender to him.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top