Salah vs Robben

[Temptation]

For one game, I'd take peak Robben over Salah.


Robben at his best was literally unstoppable and a huge match-winner.


FWIW, I'd take Bale over both in a one-off game because of his individual attributes and clutch nature.

 

[Temptation]

Robben played for Bayern in Bundesliga. Yes, he had some big performances in CL but day in, day out Bundesliga is nowhere near 2017 - current EPL that Salah played in.

That's probably the reason for the lopsided vote. That and injury record.

Voting CR7 with his 103 PL goals in 7.5 seasons over Henry when it comes to PL is pure fanboyism. CR7's 07/08 was great but so are Henry's 03/04 and Salah's 17/18. It's not clear cut best PL season ever. Then, you factor in longevity.

My Dembele vs Rashford thread was so much closer than this one lol.


Think it was decided by merely 1 or 2 votes.