Kylian Muppet

Maradona37

Well-known member
Lol, he's shown so far at the highest level in club football, he's more of a negative than positive.

He has time to change that, but doesn't look good so far.

He's probably why France plays like shit, they have to stack the Midfield with a bunch of workers to make up for his lack of effort.

Which is why if I was in change, I would keep Vini over him, Vini has shown he can get the job done.
Like I said before though, Vini has had the opportunity to play in the team without him, and with being fed and being the main man. Mbappe has not had that luxury without Vini. He's come into an unbalanced team, partly because of him admittedly. I think Real Madrid would be better if they sold Vini more than if they sold Mbappe.

it's a game of opinions, but I think Mbappe is comfortably better at football than Vinicius Junior. Both are overrated, though.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Like I said before though, Vini has had the opportunity to play in the team without him, and with being fed and being the main man. Mbappe has not had that luxury without Vini. He's come into an unbalanced team, partly because of him admittedly. I think Real Madrid would be better if they sold Vini more than if they sold Mbappe.

it's a game of opinions, but I think Mbappe is comfortably better at football than Vinicius Junior. Both are overrated, though.

Mbappe has everything in him to succeed at PSG,even last season with Luis as the coach and as the coach himself said, when Mbappe leaves they will be unstoppable.

So said

So done
 

Maradona37

Well-known member
Mbappe has everything in him to succeed at PSG,even last season with Luis as the coach and as the coach himself said, when Mbappe leaves they will be unstoppable.

So said

So done
That's true too. But don't think it's as simple as that either, correlation is not necessarily causation. I don't think PSG are brilliant just because Mbappe left lol. That does a disservice to their other players.

I'd also posit a counter argument - that if Vini was playing for PSG (instead of Kvaratskhelia) they'd be a worse team too than they are now, as he has the same flaws as Mbappe.

I am not disagreeing with you on Mbappe being overrated and having a lack of work rate - just saying that Vini is no better, as you appear to be trying to put him on a pedestal above Mbappe.
 

RedxMAK

Well-known member
His career has been a large disappointment so far. Idc about his stupid World Cup even Adil Rami won it so it doesn’t matter that much. No major club trophies and aged 27, what a disappointment…
 

soul24rage

Senior Member
What Mbappe needs at this point of his career with his mentality is similar to what Messi needs with the Argentine national team.

9 other in-field players who works hard off the ball. 3 CMs + a RW who is creative. A LB who can dominate the left wing. A number 9.

Problem is Mbappe is at the wrong club and RM will go nowhere having Mbappe, Vini and Bellingham all at the same time.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top