Manchester City

I don't give a shit. The more financially dopped clubs, the better. We already have the same clubs in the later stages of CL KOs, every year. Why not have 4-5 loaded clubs in every league and let them duke it out?
 
1) Not the scope of violation. We already discussed this twice.
- 2011/12 title is legit, because there was no PSR.
- 2013/14 was the first year of PSR 3 year monitoring system. No violation.
- 2017/18 is the only title that violates PSR.
- Post 2018 - there's no evidence to prosecute.
2) Not possible and illegal. Abramovich was removed by UK government due to sanctions imposed on Kremlin people. Abu Dhabi are not a concern for UK government, on the contrary they are a strategic partner and FA has zero authority on the matter.
3) Again impossible due to legal obstacles. Any expulsion decision goes immediately to FA with an appeal by City, so the temporary ban hangs. Pointless.
4) Relegation - yes. Whatever the form - 5th tier, 9th tier. Nobody cares.
5) Haven't been applied before. Sounds more like a hater's wish.
6) I hadn't thought about this, but yeah, very likely.

PS) Compensations are harder cases to prove, because they fall in to a "what if" category.

1) Titles are not voided just because of PSR, but also of a good chunk of the other charges under the heading of fabricating accounts
2) I don't know if it's illegal, but even then a prohibition of Man City to enter PL again under the same ownership is sufficient to have the same effect. It will force them to sale
3) No that's not true. PL has its own sovereign authority, if they decide to kick City out, then EFL has to convene and decide if they accept them and which division
- Compensations, I think, are the easiest to prove on the bases of gaining illegitimate income, such as prizes (PL winner prize for instance, CL money, etc.).

Let me repeat that any sanction that does not involve STRICTLY number 1 and at least a form of 2 will be a joke

PS: Again, most here think this will go the route it had been going with Everton and Forest.
It won't. It's unprecedented, and the sanctions will be unprecedented
 
1) Titles are not voided just because of PSR, but also of a good chunk of the other charges under the heading of fabricating accounts
2) I don't know if it's illegal, but even then a prohibition of Man City to enter PL again under the same ownership is sufficient to have the same effect. It will force them to sale
3) No that's not true. PL has its own sovereign authority, if they decide to kick City out, then EFL has to convene and decide if they accept them and which division
- Compensations, I think, are the easiest to prove on the bases of gaining illegitimate income, such as prizes (PL winner prize for instance, CL money, etc.).

Let me repeat that any sanction that does not involve STRICTLY number 1 and at least a form of 2 will be a joke

PS: Again, most here think this will go the route it had been going with Everton and Forest.
It won't. It's unprecedented, and the sanctions will be unprecedented
Let me repeat and run down on your points:

1) Wishful thinking
2) Legally impossible, the law of private property is untouchable under UK law. I already mentioned it with the example of Abramovich and Ukraine war.
3) Same. Man City cannot be paused/removed from competing by FA, unless City Group accept full guilt. A legal case and appeal.
 
Last edited:
Let me repeat and run down on your points:

1) Wishful thinking
2) Legally impossible, the law of private property is untouchable under UK law. I already mentioned it with the example of Abramovich and Ukraine war.
3) Same. Man City cannot be paused/removed from competing by FA, unless City Group accept full guilt. A legal case and appeal.

I like the fact that you post this as if you have a single clue about law and legal jurisdiction works in this case, while in fact you have no clue and conflate things such as EPL as a legal body and UK government.

Let's set things straight, so you stop misinforming the forum:
PL has the absolute legal authority to impose all of 1, 2 and 3. You should have realized it by now after all the reports about the guilty verdict and how sanctions work the last 2 weeks. But you are stubborn enough to insist, when the reality is clear as daylight

Let AI then help you accepting the reality you don't like:
- " Section F of the Premier League Handbook
The legal framework for the test is permanently codified in Section F: Owners’ and Directors’ Test of the official handbook
  • The Disqualification Rule: Under Section F, if an owner or director is hit with a "Disqualifying Event," they are legally prohibited from acting as an officer or holding a controlling stake in a club.
  • The Mandate to Divest: Once a Disqualifying Event occurs, the Premier League Board issues an official notice. The individual or entity is stripped of their "fit and proper" status and given a strict, legally binding timeframe to divest their shares and exit the club completely.
- " Officially Enhanced Powers (The March 2023 Rules Update)
Following unanimous approval from its clubs, the league officially toughened these rules to explicitly grant itself the power to remove sitting executives and owners. The official announcement can be found via the Premier League OADT Statement.
These rules state that the Premier League has the authority to disqualify owners for:
  • Fraud and Deception: The list of disqualifying criminal and regulatory offenses includes fraud, corruption, and tax evasion. Providing false accounting or deliberately deceiving a league commission falls directly into this category.
  • Ongoing Investigations: Crucially, the league now has the specific power to block or suspend individuals who are simply under investigation for conduct that would result in a disqualifying event if proven.
  • Annual Due Diligence: The league does not just test owners when they buy a club; they conduct mandatory annual checks on incumbent owners to ensure continuous compliance. "
- "The Power to Expel (Rule B.6 & Rule W.64)
The Premier League Handbook outlines a two-step mechanism required to permanently remove a member club:
  • The Commission’s Recommendation (Rule W.64.4): Following Manchester City’s recent guilty verdict on the 114 financial charges, an independent disciplinary commission has the power to recommend expulsion from the Premier League.
  • The 15-Club Vote (Rule B.6): A recommendation to expel is not automatic. Under Rule B.6, it requires a three-quarters majority vote of the member clubs to officially ratify the expulsion. This means 15 out of the other 19 clubs must vote "yes" to strip Manchester City of its share in the league.
Why the Appeal Does NOT Go to the FA
The Premier League is an entirely self-governing entity operating under its own rulebook. If Manchester City challenges an expulsion or other severe sanction, the process works as follows:
  • The Premier League Appeal Board: Under Section W of the handbook, the appeal is heard by a newly formed, three-person internal Premier League Appeal Board (typically chaired by a senior former High Court judge). It does not get referred to an FA Regulatory Commission.
  • Final and Binding Resolution: Under the Premier League's rules, the verdict delivered by this internal Appeal Board is final and binding. The FA has no jurisdiction to overturn or hear a secondary appeal regarding Premier League rule breaches.

- "The "Catch-All" Sanction Rule (Rule W.51.7)
In the Premier League Handbook, the explicit penalties available to a disciplinary commission are listed under Rule W.51. While specific penalties like fines, points deductions, and expulsions are explicitly named, the rulebook contains a powerful sub-clause under Rule W.51.7. This clause grants the independent panel the authority to impose “such other penalty as it shall think fit”. Legal experts confirm this "catch-all" wording functions as an open mandate, allowing the commission to invent or apply any custom sporting penalty it deems appropriate, including the total nullification of past titles."
 
Don’t see Birdy foaming with same intensity about PSG, since Twerkbele plays for them :lol:

You have a weak memory then.
Because I always said the same about them since Qataris took over.
The fact that they now have a likable team under a great coach is irrelevant.

The problem this will never happen in either France or UEFA.
The French government has long time bended over to them and the French league does not have either the integrity or courage to fight financial corruption of that scale. As for UEFA, as things stand with KElaifi promoted to ECA chairman and corrupted Infantino protecting him before, it does not look likely. If things change in the future within UEFA, things could happen
 
- "The "Catch-All" Sanction Rule (Rule W.51.7)
In the Premier League Handbook, the explicit penalties available to a disciplinary commission are listed under Rule W.51. While specific penalties like fines, points deductions, and expulsions are explicitly named, the rulebook contains a powerful sub-clause under Rule W.51.7. This clause grants the independent panel the authority to impose “such other penalty as it shall think fit”. Legal experts confirm this "catch-all" wording functions as an open mandate, allowing the commission to invent or apply any custom sporting penalty it deems appropriate, including the total nullification of past titles."
There's no such reading on this W.51.7 rule that says nullifying of titles. I didn't find it in the 2023 handbook your AI cited. Doesn't exist in the 2026/27 handbook, either. The new article is W.64 and there's nothing about title stripping.

I can be wrong about certain things, but you did hallucinate that part.
 
Last edited:
There's no such reading on this W.51.7 rule that says nullifying of titles. I didn't find it in the 2023 handbook your AI cited. Doesn't exist in the 2026/27 handbook, either. The new article is W.64 and there's nothing about title stripping.
You should be ashamed on lying to me. I can be wrong about certain things, but you are a certified donkey.

Dude you are either dumb or you play it very well...

The AI quoted the wrong number, but the article is there, and the statement is there. Current 26/27 handbook, clause W64.7:
"impose upon the Respondent any combination of the foregoing or such other penalty as it shall think fit" Exactly the phrase the AI quoted.

Oh, what a surprise, huh? All the reliable journalist have been telling the truth the last 2 weeks that PL has the authority to strip titles...

What about all the other crap you referred to as legal expert about PL's legal jurisdiction to expel a team or an owner?
Yes, you were 100% wrong, but you came here in all arrogance to play it smart...

Stop misinforming the forum, google something if you don't know, and keep your agenda for yourself.

City are getting punished, and are getting punished hard.
Hopefully both title stripping and force sale will be there
 
What I was wrong about is EPL power of removing Directors. It's not clear to me in this text the distinction between Directors and Owners. Section A says Director is every person controlling the club. Then in section F it's titled Owners' and Directors' Test (OADT).

Reading down section F and the conditions to remove directors are quite severe. Like Abramovich's case - a person is disqualified for sanctions by UK government, involved in fraud, illegal activities, etc. Thus the whole thing is not happening without government interference.
 
Last edited:
What I was wrong about is EPL power of removing Directors. It's not clear to me in this text the distinction between Directors and Owners. Section A says Director is every person controlling the club. Then in section F it's titled Owners' and Directors' Test (OADT).

Reading down section F and the conditions to remove directors are quite severe. Like Abramovich's case - a person is disqualified for sanctions by UK government, involved in fraud, illegal activities, etc. Thus the whole thing is not happening without government interference.
:lol: As the saying goes "the smart person accepts, the idiot insists"...

No you were not wrong only about that. You were wrong about everything you said.
You argued PL are not allowed to take these decisions. You were proven wrong IN WRITING (because it was not enough for you to just read what all media outlets were saying about PL authority), in the very handbook with the rules, that PL can impose all the aforementioned sanctions one by one.

And you keep insisting that the provisions of the Premier Leagues statures list general crimes under UK law.
Section F quotes the rules that warrant removing directors, and they lie some pages back...

All you have to do is read.
I know reading and reading comprehension is difficult...
 
:lol: As the saying goes "the smart person accepts, the idiot insists"...

No you were not wrong only about that. You were wrong about everything you said.
You argued PL are not allowed to take these decisions. You were proven wrong IN WRITING (because it was not enough for you to just read what all media outlets were saying about PL authority), in the very handbook with the rules, that PL can impose all the aforementioned sanctions one by one.

And you keep insisting that the provisions of the Premier Leagues statures list general crimes under UK law.
Section F quotes the rules that warrant removing directors, and they lie some pages back...

All you have to do is read.
I know reading and reading comprehension is difficult...
You argued much more than that.

We'll see who's the donkey at the end.
 
You argued much more than that.

We'll see who's the donkey at the end.

No mate, I argued precisely that, and you are already proven wrong.

I listed 6 punishments PL can impose, and you questioned their legal authority to do so.
You were proven wrong, as PL has the authority to do so, irrespective of what they will decide eventually.

Man up, and admit you were wrong
 
The very same sentence exists in the current handbook, but the number is different. W64.7.

But this is a 'lie' for you :lol:
OK
W64.7 means "impose upon the Respondent any combination of the foregoing or such other penalty as it shall think fit". I wish you good luck.
 
W64.7 means "impose upon the Respondent any combination of the foregoing or such other penalty as it shall think fit". I wish you good luck.

That's exactly what the AI wrote. Verbatim.
So in what way it was a 'lie'?
 
Too much emphasis here on what the EPL (read top legacy clubs) can and cannot do against City. Fact is, Cas, IN PART, rejected the case against City back in 2020, ruling that insufficient evidence (the leaked emails) existed to prove that Manchester City's owners had funded sponsorship payments. After all, it's not about what we know happened but about proving that it did! Suddenly, just like that, many years later, the EPL stumbled upon incriminating evidence strong enough to surpass reasonable doubt when Cas IN PART rejected it in 2020? 🤭

If the EPL is so confident, allow the case to be heard by a court which isn't financially or emotionally invested in the outcome.
 
That's exactly what the AI wrote. Verbatim.
So in what way it was a 'lie'?
The lie part I accuse you of is the last paragraph. This "shall think fit" as "catch-all" render you either wrote yourself or your AI hallucinated is not it. What I'm disgusted by is selling this to the forum as the ultimate truth.
 
The lie part I accuse you of is the last paragraph. This "shall think fit" as "catch-all" render you either wrote yourself or your AI hallucinated is not it. What I'm disgusted by is selling this to the forum as the ultimate truth.

It's common reading comprehension. The rulebook gives the committee absolute power to impose any penalty they shall think fit.

It is true, and it has been confirmed by all media outlets.

Wake up or keep living in your state of denial
 
Back
Top