16 - Rodri

I’m yet to see him play a good incisive line-breaking ball.

I think the team is in a bit of an identity crisis when he is given the strings to dictate from deep, as he’s inclined to horizontal passes and slowing the tempo instead of the usual Flick blitzkreig tactics.

Today was the worst example of this as we looked like Koeman’s Barca.
 
Going to say it now as nobody has questioned it, but Rodri, though he has been fairly good here so far against cannon fodder, he certainly doesn't look like the Rodri of old.

I initially thought it was him taking it easy after a bad injury, but yesterday he was trying hard and looked slow on the turn and struggled to get back at times, just as he did at City last season. Commentators on my feed said the same.

It was the worry some of us here raised in the summer. Not that we were ever going to get a poor player, but that we weren't going to get the pre-injury Rodri that would be befitting of paying 70m + on a 30 year old for.

And the jury is still out on that one.

I wrote the above a month ago and have been genuinely baffled at the constant praise he has been getting here since.

He doesn't look like the player City had at all, and has developed some of the punch drunk / doped up play, and look, that is so reminiscent of Jules Kounde. The amount of simple passes he has misplaced has been shocking.

But by far the worse thing is the lack of desire. Rodri at City, when they were losing, was breaking his back trying to get his team back in the game, being a nasty, angry fucker all over the pitch. For Spain too. He looked like he genuinely hurt and cared in their shirts.

He's shown none of that here, which was natural since he won every game, but nothing in that regard in the last two losses either.

I hope he doesn't think he has done us a favour coming here, as that would be foolish, as this is the only big club he has every player for.
 
Mister doesn't know how to use this tool.

It's in these kind of high intensity game where a much better coach says he can't play with Pedri. They need Fabian for better balance
 
Ya him with Pedri on the pitch has not really worked out for both club and country. We should try Rodri-Olmo-FDJ when olmo is back
 
I wrote the above a month ago and have been genuinely baffled at the constant praise he has been getting here since.

He doesn't look like the player City had at all, and has developed some of the punch drunk / doped up play, and look, that is so reminiscent of Jules Kounde. The amount of simple passes he has misplaced has been shocking.

But by far the worse thing is the lack of desire. Rodri at City, when they were losing, was breaking his back trying to get his team back in the game, being a nasty, angry fucker all over the pitch. For Spain too. He looked like he genuinely hurt and cared in their shirts.

He's shown none of that here, which was natural since he won every game, but nothing in that regard in the last two losses either.

I hope he doesn't think he has done us a favour coming here, as that would be foolish, as this is the only big club he has every player for.
Man city and Spain have both been bigger than us in recent times. This is the problem with us Barca fans, which also explains our reactions to these losses
 
I'm not sure about him.

He has an excellent reputation, but if we go purely off what we have seen, does he make the positive impact that his reputation implies?

It feels to me that he is often too conservative with the ball and he isn't progressing the team forward.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gol
I’m yet to see him play a good incisive line-breaking ball.

I think the team is in a bit of an identity crisis when he is given the strings to dictate from deep, as he’s inclined to horizontal passes and slowing the tempo instead of the usual Flick blitzkreig tactics.

Today was the worst example of this as we looked like Koeman’s Barca.
This is a good point about recruitment. He's played in very possession-heavy, slow build-up systems at City and with Spain. Particularly with City, their buildup was very slow burn.

Does that match a system where the entire point is to have ultra-fast transitions?

Great player but we might have missed with this one, because it is not like Flick is super tactically flexible.
 
I don't think you guys should expect line breaking passes from Rodri because that's simply not his job.

Much like with FDJ. It is no coincidence that both players never really attempt doing those. It's not that they are not able, it is part of Flick's plan.

It's not about that. But he couldn't do his thing yasterday. Get the ball, keep it, maintain control. And that's what worries me.

Even made some unusual passing mistakes and you could see it all about his frustration when he pushed Bernardo his ex teammate over nothing. You don't expect it from a player like him who is calm.
 
We're trying to turn him into Goretzka. It should not be his job to follow players 40m away from his position, just because some CB decides to go rambo mode and abandon his position.

You ask him to do these crazy long runs to cover whatever holes we create for ourselves with our crap positioning, he ain't gonna do shite else but look like a 30 year old following faster and younger players and struggling to keep up.

Have a feeling he doesn't care much for Flick's tactics also, came dangerously close to criticizing our poor defensive shape in interviews two or three times.

If we don't know how to use him well would've been better to invest the money someplace else.
 
Last edited:
You can tell by the look in his eyes he really wanted the win yesterday. Just so he could give it to Madrid a bit more.

He came in and said his objective is to win the CL. He's probably looking at our tactics and thinking damn this will be a lot more difficult than I thought.

For flickball maybe you need a more high energy DM like caicedo.
 
Btw. Just a series of frames, and it's not always this bad, but there are many more situations like this.

We do not play him as a DM, we play him as a box to box at least half the time.

With Spain, very fast someone would show up in that hole and present an option to allow Pedri to complete the good progressive pass, then retreat a bit and be ready either to stop a potential counter, or serve as a pass back option to initiate a new attack. Usually Olmo, and sometimes Oyarzabal.

rodri.jpg


How the hell are you gonna bother the opponent if you don't move to provide options on the ball? Rodri just drives into traffic and loses the ball here. Neither Pedri, nor especially Fermin show any sign of willingness to get on the ball and ask Madrid questions. Fermin doesn't even play as a midfielder most of the time. He plays as a 2nd striker. He is marking himself out behind Tchouameni the whole time.

There's no triangles in our midfield, it's all very disjointed. With Spain it's the opposite.
 
Last edited:
100% agree, not even sure it's a fitness problem. Ironically the MF that everyone think is overloaded is our main issue. PSG and Madrid exposed this and Atletico will do the same. Flick needs to find quickly the best formula
 
100% agree, not even sure it's a fitness problem. Ironically the MF that everyone think is overloaded is our main issue. PSG and Madrid exposed this and Atletico will do the same. Flick needs to find quickly the best formula

No, no the midfield is underloaded for us. On the ball that's the main difference between Spain and Barcelona. Spain isn't letting anyone tell them where to play.

What Mourinho did is set up as in "this is the midfield box I loaded with players, you don't get inside this space easily, and you play around it because we say so".

The Barcelona and Spain way is to take on the challenge, and dig holes in that structure, little by little, first small, than bigger and bigger, as the passes get faster, pass and move, pass and move, and as the movement gets more complex so is the task of the defensive block. To achieve this you have to constantly have players moving around the ball in central zones.

Barcelona under Flick accepts it and tries to bypass it. That's why we planted Fermin in their backline, at the cost of low midfield coverage, sometimes inside the box created by the 4-5 Madrid midfielders there was not even one Barca player operating.

The main template was to use Pedri and Rodri to bring the ball wide constantly to Lamine. Hoping Lamine takes an action, wins a 1 vs 1, and then Fermin gets into play by creating overloads on the flank. Problem is Lamine is not Messi to guarantee that 1 vs 1 he will pass anyone and leave him in the dirt sometimes with as little as a body feint. He can be blocked rather easily. So when you give the ball to Lamine to do his 1 vs 1 stuff, you may end up with a very poor result where Lamine tries some fancy stuff and loses ball after ball. Which is what happened, and which is why Fermin was nowhere to be found. Because his role was conditioned by whatever Yamal managed to do on the ball. Yamal did little, and then Fermin was basically irrelevant as a midfielder in the game for us.

By comparison, when Spain bring the ball to Lamine it isn't to always have him engaging the opponent 1 vs 1. Often the purpose is to shift the defensive block. They ask the question, OK, do you now shift your entire block to the right to stop Lamine? They usually did that. So they had Lamine in a very different role to what we're used to seeing at Barcelona, releasing the ball much more quickly and with much fewer risky individual actions.

Faster ball circulation meant that whenever the opponent shifted their block to neutralize Yamal, the any quick switches back in midfield opened up gaps. Gaps that Olmo, Baena, Rodri, Fabian, Oyarzabal could operate in and do damage. But they did that damage because they had the numbers.
 
Last edited:
No, no the midfield is underloaded for us. On the ball that's the main difference between Spain and Barcelona. Spain isn't letting anyone tell them where to play.

What Mourinho did is set up as in "this is the midfield box I loaded with players, you don't get inside this space easily, and you play around it because we say so".

The Barcelona and Spain way is to take on the challenge, and dig holes in that structure, little by little, first small, than bigger and bigger, as the passes get faster, pass and move, pass and move, and as the movement gets more complex so is the task of the defensive block. To achieve this you have to constantly have players moving around the ball in central zones.

Barcelona under Flick accepts it and tries to bypass it. That's why we planted Fermin in their backline, at the cost of low midfield coverage, sometimes inside the box created by the 4-5 Madrid midfielders there was not even one Barca player operating.

The main template was to use Pedri and Rodri to bring the ball wide constantly to Lamine. Hoping Lamine takes an action, wins a 1 vs 1, and then Fermin gets into play by creating overloads on the flank. Problem is Lamine is not Messi to guarantee that 1 vs 1 he will pass anyone and leave him in the dirt sometimes with as little as a body feint. He can be blocked rather easily. So when you give the ball to Lamine to do his 1 vs 1 stuff, you may end up with a very poor result where Lamine tries some fancy stuff and loses ball after ball. Which is what happened, and which is why Fermin was nowhere to be found. Because his role was conditioned by whatever Yamal managed to do on the ball. Yamal did little, and then Fermin was basically irrelevant as a midfielder in the game for us.

By comparison, when Spain bring the ball to Lamine it isn't to always have him engaging the opponent 1 vs 1. Often the purpose is to shift the defensive block. They ask the question, OK, do you now shift your entire block to the right to stop Lamine? They usually did that. So they had Lamine in a very different role to what we're used to seeing at Barcelona, releasing the ball much more quickly and with much fewer risky individual actions.

Faster ball circulation meant that whenever the opponent shifted their block to neutralize Yamal, the any quick switches back in midfield opened up gaps. Gaps that Olmo, Baena, Rodri, Fabian, Oyarzabal could operate in and do damage. But they did that damage because they had the numbers.
(y)
 
Xavi is similar when facing a low block. Just more patient, more cautious to not allow counters. But it was boring, because Xavi is rigid positionally and extremely stubborn and inflexible.

The main template of Xavi vs a low block scenario was similar to Flick, just with better midfield coverage. Bring the ball wide and try 1 vs 1. Which is why he loved Dembele. Which is why he tried to use Raphinha wide. Midfield coverage is not enough in itself if you don't add a high degree a fluidity. If an opponent clogs the midfield a lot, just good positioning is not enough anymore. You need a lot of movement.

So you have Guardiola, and De La Fuente as very good positional play managers who are also innovative and constantly evolving. You have Xavi as the worse, more rigid, variant which shows some of the problems of this setup when not implemented in a fluid way. Extremely boring possession that doesn't really translates to efficient chance creation unless someone does something really great.

From this trio you kind of move away a bit, but not that much, and you have Luis Enrique who is extremely flexible and would play very differently based on opponent. Flick is 2-3 moves even more away from positional play. Arteta is somewhat the defensive version of Lucho with elements from Simeone. But if you look at Bayern - PSG, 1-1, the setup of Lucho was extremely similar to what you may see from Arteta.

The best option for us to transition from Flick is Luis Enrique by a mile. Would take over what Flick built and would develop it nicely into something more complex, while keeping some of it, dropping the 10 role, and ensuring midfield superiority by having a proper trio there instead of a classic double pivot.

I would also like De La Fuente, with all the risk because he never managed a club before and may not work out. But his Spain version was brilliant in how easy it made teams play his game with solutions for everything anybody threw at him. And he is authoritarian. Handles Lamine Yamal perfectly and takes no shite.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top