Manchester United

iamrohith said:

What is there to feel sad about Welbeck. They have Falcao, Rooney and RVP. And isn't welbeck bad?

Click to expand...

Unbiased United said:

Di Maria and Falcao might be two fancy signings if you want to look at it like that (although very welcome still!), but the other four in Shaw, Herrera, Blind and Rojo are all very much needed. It's not been a perfect window, but it's not been far off. Sure we still have some 'mid-lower tier' players, but with our injured players back, they won't need to be seeing much game time at all. Feel free to mention which of our players out of the strongest eleven are in that lower bracket you mention. I don't think there are any.

De Gea
Rafael
Smalling
Rojo
Shaw
Herrera
Carrick
Blind
Di Maria
Rooney
RVP
Falcao
Januzaj

That's more than eleven and there isn't a mid-low tier player amongst them.


I'd be more worried about Liverpool's transfer window if I were you. They had the money and CL football on offer, to make three or four world class signings to really to that next step up, but instead have ended up with the best part of ten average ones.

Rodgers is a good manager but why he failed to spend some of that money on some class defenders is beyond me. Moreno might do well but Lovren had his level at Southampton.. You'll score loads again this season, but I can see your defence letting in just as many as last season.

Click to expand...

Martindn said:

Think this is more than enough for top 4, problem is keeping everyone fit (and getting them fit!)

Spoiler: team

Click to expand...

SwiftGuyver said:

wow! you're so unbiased!

it all depends how your tiering system works and how many tiers are involved but if you have top/mid/low i'd personally argue that Rafael, Smalling/Jones, Rojo, Shaw (for now), Herrera, Carrick (nowadays), Blind & Januzaj (atm) are mid tier players. Shaw & Januzaj have the potential to move into the top tier though. Rooney is inconsistent, RVP is injury prone and therefore far too inconsistent, Falcao is a risk after 3 knee problems during his career and it might be tough for him to get back to his best after the latest one at the age of 29 but if he can he is top class and a 1 year loan is worth a punt. Di María & de Gea are the only truly top tier players in that list for me. obviously you disagree.

Liverpool have never really signed already recognised 'world class' players for whatever reason. maybe Rodgers isn't obsessed/blinded by names on a page just like Fergie wasn't. he clearly seems more focused on the team balance/spirit and the system and i'd personally back Moreno, Manquillo, Lovren, Lallana, Can & Marković to all do well this season. Balotelli is a risk but he might prove people wrong. i doubt Lambert will feature much.

end of the day Utd fans think one thing and Liverpool fans think another, it's always been that way for the most part! the reality is nobody really knows how things will pan out and we'll just have to wait and see. there will be surprises though guaranteed!

Click to expand...

Unbiased United said:

I'm as reasonable football fan as you'll find. Just because I happen to think my teams players are a tad above 'low/mid tier' doesn't make me otherwise, and I'm sure most impartial fans would agree with the players I mentioned being better than that. All I said about the list I wrote was, and I quote " ....That's more than eleven and there isn't a mid-low tier player amongst them". 'Mid-low tier', would suggest bottom half of the PL, and that is just ridiculous. If you think otherwise, yet just so happen to think that all the Liverpool buys will do well, then I think you should have a good think about who might actually be the biased one.

Liverpool have a very good exciting team, and as much as I hate to admit it, they are great to watch at the moment. Also, in Rodgers they have a good young manager, and I'd back them to do well again this season. However, United have had the much better transfer window and I'm convinced that we'll have a great season too once we get the injured players back fit and the new players involved. Our season starts on the 14th September.

Click to expand...

Unbiased United said:

I'm as reasonable football fan as you'll find. Just because I happen to think my teams players are a tad above 'low/mid tier' doesn't make me otherwise, and I'm sure most impartial fans would agree with the players I mentioned being better than that. All I said about the list I wrote was, and I quote " ....That's more than eleven and there isn't a mid-low tier player amongst them". 'Mid-low tier', would suggest bottom half of the PL, and that is just ridiculous. If you think otherwise, yet just so happen to think that all the Liverpool buys will do well, then I think you should have a good think about who might actually be the biased one.

Liverpool have a very good exciting team, and as much as I hate to admit it, they are great to watch at the moment. Also, in Rodgers they have a good young manager, and I'd back them to do well again this season. However, United have had the much better transfer window and I'm convinced that we'll have a great season too once we get the injured players back fit and the new players involved. Our season starts on the 14th September.

Click to expand...

Semi-Neutral said:

Yeah, that's a pretty strong starting XI, but what about their bench? They've got RVP, sure, but then it's Young, Valencia, Fellaini, Fletcher... I really don't understand why Kagawa and Welbeck were sold, they both would have been great for depth, as it is a few injuries up top and suddenly mediocre players and creeping in to the starters (as we've already witnessed their past few games).

Click to expand...

Banana-Rama said:

if we are going to play a diamond then i agree there is no real quality back up in the 2 centre mid positions, however van gaal can easily change the formation to 4-2-3-1 and bring januzaj into the lineup, there is also players like rvp, carrick that can come in along with james wilson who is a very good striker prospect. van gaal wants to bring in strootman from roma when he is back from injury, i wouldn't rule out that deal happening in january, tho next summer is more likely...

Click to expand...