Hummels or Kompany

AvocadoCake

New member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #1

Not who you'd rather have (because of age difference), but who's better?

 

M

mitkoa7x

Guest

• Jun 20, 2012

• #2

Hummels for me, Kompany is beast as well

 

Aryagorn

Improvin' Perfection!!

• Jun 20, 2012

• #3

Hummels... But Kompany is the one that would suit Pique the better, for us.

 

D

Doobs

The Messiah

• Jun 20, 2012

• #4

The Hummer of course

 

Hellsangel

Member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #5

Kompany.. not even a contest for me

 

Galning

Moderator

• Jun 20, 2012

• #6

Hummels!!

 

M

mitkoa7x

Guest

• Jun 20, 2012

• #7

Hellsangel said:

Kompany.. not even a contest for me

Click to expand...

You're from Belgium, you're obviously biased. But I respect your opinion no matter how wrong its

 

Grunberg

New member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #8

Hummels definitely for me!

 

mixer

New member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #9

Kompany

 

abual3bed1

New member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #10

both are great but Kompany is a personal favourite. maybe because I watched Kompany in action more than I watched Hummels.

 

ranjix

Jefecito

• Jun 20, 2012

• #11

Hummels!

 

Barcaman

Administrator

Staff member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #12

Could have gotten Kompany from HSV when he was on a cheap. Hummels also, as he had expiring contract and only signed an extension recently.
But apparently our scouting in Bundesliga sucks.

 

Aryagorn

Improvin' Perfection!!

• Jun 20, 2012

• #13

To realise Hummels is awesome you don't even need to have a scouting network in Germany...

 

Edman

New member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #14

Hummels is great but Kompany is about as good as it gets for a central defender.

 

D

DucdeOrléans

New member

• Jun 20, 2012

• #15

I love both players and the type of central defender they both represent but despite having wanted Hummels for 2 years now (see my posts before) there is no doubt that Kompany is the better player right now. Might change in the near future though.

But it's a shame that we will not buy any of them.