Perfect XI ?

B

blueduck

Guest
This would be my Ideal team:

------------------Shay Given---------------------

Alves--------Terry-------Ferdinand-----Ashley Cole


Messi--------Essien--------Gerrard---------Iniesta


-------------Rooney---------Villa-----------------

I suppose I am a bit biased because Im English :)

What would your Perfect XI be ?
 
Canto

Canto

Johan Dalin part II
--------------------Given-----------------------------

Lahm---------Rio--------------Vida-----------------Evra

Ronaldo------------Xavi-----------Essien------------Messi


---------------------Rooney-------------Torres-----------

bench:Cassials Ramos Gerrad Ribery Inestia Villa Benzeema
 
B

blueduck

Guest
Canto said:
--------------------Given-----------------------------

Lahm---------Rio--------------Vida-----------------Evra

Ronaldo------------Xavi-----------Essien------------Messi


---------------------Rooney-------------Torres-----------

bench:Cassials Ramos Gerrad Ribery Inestia Villa Benzeema
Click to expand...

Some good choices, Casillas would of been my third choice behind Cech.

Gerrard imo is the best centre mid in the world as he can do everything.

Vidic can have some shoccking games every now and then too.

Torres would of been my second choice too, or possibly Aguero.:D
 
Zqa-

Zqa-

New member
Yes, but he's no where, not even friggin' near Casillas or Buffon. Heck, even Van der Sar is better if you ask me.
 
Canto

Canto

Johan Dalin part II
blueduck said:
Some good choices, Casillas would of been my third choice behind Cech.

Gerrard imo is the best centre mid in the world as he can do everything.

Vidic can have some shoccking games every now and then too.

Torres would of been my second choice too, or possibly Aguero.:D
Click to expand...

Thanks mate :cool:

i dunno i rate Casillas ahead of Cech really i wouldn't rate Cech that highly any more after his head injury he is dodgy under the high ball and crosses he can certainly be got at!

yeah i rate Gerrard highly but i rate Xavi and Essien more and id also have Inestia ahead of him in there too but Gerrard would be 4th in my list! i think Xavi and Essien would complement each other perfectly too!

the only two real bad games i remember him having in the past two seasons have been the two games against the scousers this season other then that he has been immense as you know from the match on Sunday ;)

Torres is the best striker in the World IMO and him and Rooney together would be near perfect strike combination IMO :cool:
 
Benzema10

Benzema10

Official Lyon representative
My team:

------------------Van-Der-Sar--------------------

Alves--------Terry-------Ferdinand-----Ashley Cole

---------------------Essien----------------------

----------Gerrard--------------Iniesta-------------

Messi--------------------------------------Rooney

--------------------Torres------------------------

3 from ManU
3 from Barca
3 from chelsea
2 from liverpool

I can put Xabi Alonso at Iniesta's place.
 
Last edited:
B

blueduck

Guest
Canto said:
Thanks mate :cool:

i dunno i rate Casillas ahead of Cech really i wouldn't rate Cech that highly any more after his head injury he is dodgy under the high ball and crosses he can certainly be got at!

yeah i rate Gerrard highly but i rate Xavi and Essien more and id also have Inestia ahead of him in there too but Gerrard would be 4th in my list! i think Xavi and Essien would complement each other perfectly too!

the only two real bad games i remember him having in the past two seasons have been the two games against the scousers this season other then that he has been immense as you know from the match on Sunday ;)

Torres is the best striker in the World IMO and him and Rooney together would be near perfect strike combination IMO :cool:
Click to expand...

As I am a City fan I should hate Rooney. But I would have him as the best forward in the world just ahead of Torres and Villa.

He gives 110% every game no matter what. He scores, sets up goals and can defend too.

The only bad things you could say are that he has a bit of a temper and should score about 5 more every season (oh and he looks like Shrek:lol:)

Vidic is a good player but he's too dirty, he makes fouls to get out of mistakes because he wasn't in the right position. Ferdinand helps him look a better player than he really is Imo.
 
Canto

Canto

Johan Dalin part II
blueduck said:
As I am a City fan I should hate Rooney. But I would have him as the best forward in the world just ahead of Torres and Villa.

He gives 110% every game no matter what. He scores, sets up goals and can defend too.

The only bad things you could say are that he has a bit of a temper and should score about 5 more every season (oh and he looks like Shrek:lol:)

Vidic is a good player but he's too dirty, he makes fouls to get out of mistakes because he wasn't in the right position. Ferdinand helps him look a better player than he really is Imo.
Click to expand...

Yeah and as an Irish man and a United fan i was gutted to see Given go to you ;) he really will win fook all now ;):p

but i get what your saying and i agree i love Rooney :wub: but i think that if you take away his temper and his passion you take away alot of his game! i wouldn't change anything about him except maybe his consistency as he would go on a run of 10 games where he is untouchable then he would go through a bad patch of maybe 5 games and then be untouchable again after that etc

i dunno mate you picked Terry and you could argue that Carvalho makes terry look better ;) you've got to admit though he should have won the player of the year as Stephen Ireland should have won the young player of the year
 
B

blueduck

Guest
Benzema10 said:
My team:

----------------------------Van-Der-Sar--------------------

Alves--------Terry-------Ferdinand-----Ashley Cole

-------------------------Essien----------------------

------------Gerrard-------------Iniesta---------------

Messi--------------------------------------Rooney

----------------------------Torres--------------------------

3 from ManU
3 from Barca
3 from chelsea
2 from liverpool

I can put Xabi Alonso at Iniesta's place.
Click to expand...

Imo these are the best players in the world and should be in everyones top team without any arguements
 
B

blueduck

Guest
Canto said:
Yeah and as an Irish man and a United fan i was gutted to see Given go to you ;) he really will win fook all now ;):p

but i get what your saying and i agree i love Rooney :wub: but i think that if you take away his temper and his passion you take away alot of his game! i wouldn't change anything about him except maybe his consistency as he would go on a run of 10 games where he is untouchable then he would go through a bad patch of maybe 5 games and then be untouchable again after that etc

i dunno mate you picked Terry and you could argue that Carvalho makes terry look better ;) you've got to admit though he should have won the player of the year as Stephen Ireland should have won the young player of the year
Click to expand...

I suppose, Vidic is without a doubt one of the best headers of the ball and can deal with crosses easily, but when quality players dribble towards him he just looks a bit clumsy imo

Terry is quality because he can head the ball as well as Vidic and is very consistent (except at taking peno's ;))

I can't make-up my mind on Van Der Sar, He can make some real "school boy errors" at times and United's defence means he doesn't have much to do. But to be fair he's there in the big games and makes the important saves.
 
B

beautifulgame

Guest
I can't believe the times we live in. A world of football where Terry is considered a top defender is absurd; makes me want to cry. He's not even the best defender in his team: Alex and Carvalho are miles ahead.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Home of Barca Fans

Top