Hummels or Piqué?

Hummels or Piqué?


  • Total voters
    55

zanela

Senior Member
Your defender for all seasons and occasions?

Criteria:

  • Reliability
  • Consistency
  • Leadership/temperament
  • Pure defensive and
  • ball playing skills
 
F

Flavia

Guest
Based on their current form, or on their best possible form?
 
F

Flavia

Guest
based on my criteria (you can add your own ofc). ;)

I think my ques is self-explanatory, no? :p

It doesn't say if it's based on their form now or not, that's why I asked. Because currently, it's Hummels. But if based on their peak, I'd pick Pique.
 

Neymessi

Active member
There comes some bias for the players of the club you support but not this much.pique < 1/2 hummels atm for me.
 

zanela

Senior Member
It doesn't say if it's based on their form now or not, that's why I asked. Because currently, it's Hummels. But if based on their peak, I'd pick Pique.

Form obv. fluctuates over a season. My question has less to do with form, but more about their gen. abilities and what they bring to the pitch on a weekly basis.
 
F

Flavia

Guest
Form obv. fluctuates over a season. My question has less to do with form, but more about their gen. abilities and what they bring to the pitch on a weekly basis.

Then it's based on the present :p
Hummels it is, Pique right now is not as good as Hummels is.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top