Robert Fernandez

hulinat

New member
Pogba? top player? what has he exactly done for united to justify his price tag? he's actually worse than gomes.
 

serghei

Senior Member
Pogba? top player? what has he exactly done for united to justify his price tag? he's actually worse than gomes.

I don't know. Maybe world champion at Under 20 (and Best Player of the Tournament winner) with France as captain, several scudettos with Juventus, CL final with Juventus, Euro finalist with France in 2016 and several other achievements. But never mind those. If you watch him play, he is without a doubt the best and the most creative young midfielder in the world. And please don't mention Verratti.
 
Last edited:

hulinat

New member
I don't know. Maybe world champion at Under 20 (and Best Player of the Tournament winner) with France as captain, several scudettos with Juventus, CL final with Juventus, Euro finalist with France in 2016 and several other achievements. But never mind those. If you watch him play, he is without a doubt the best and the most creative young midfielder in the world. And please don't mention Verratti.

If I watch him play I see an overrated hyped clumsy showpony. Football is a team sport u know but if u wanna play that game: Thiago, euro u-17 winner, euro u-21 winner twice as captain of Spain, Cl winner, 6 league titles, 2 domestic cup titles, club world cup winner, and yeah hes pretty creative too.
 

serghei

Senior Member
If I watch him play I see an overrated hyped clumsy showpony. Football is a team sport u know but if u wanna play that game: Thiago, euro u-17 winner, euro u-21 winner twice as captain of Spain, Cl winner, 6 league titles, 2 domestic cup titles, club world cup winner, and yeah hes pretty creative too.

Except Pogba was a key player in that Juventus side. Thiago wasn't at Barca, and he isn't at Bayern either. But yea, you can consider him whatever you want.
 

khaled_a_d

Senior Member
If I watch him play I see an overrated hyped clumsy showpony. Football is a team sport u know but if u wanna play that game: Thiago, euro u-17 winner, euro u-21 winner twice as captain of Spain, Cl winner, 6 league titles, 2 domestic cup titles, club world cup winner, and yeah hes pretty creative too.

Let's say Pogba is overrated player as you think. He went for something like 105M. The overrated young midfielder.
Imagine going for a good one now. how much he will cost? How much will Thiago cost to convince Bayern to let him go?
You are basucqlly proving serghei point even more
 

Barcaman

Administrator
Staff member
Let's say Pogba is overrated player as you think. He went for something like 105M. The overrated young midfielder.
Imagine going for a good one now. how much he will cost? How much will Thiago cost to convince Bayern to let him go?
You are basucqlly proving serghei point even more

I can. Gundogan for 20. Kante for 30. Good deals can be done if you are smart.
 

khaled_a_d

Senior Member
I can. Gundogan for 20. Kante for 30. Good deals can be done if you are smart.

We got Umtiti & Rakitic for gr8 deals too. City paid like 100M for Sane & Stones. Gudogan went for 25. had injury history,got injured before signing. came back and once started getting into form get injured again and out for the season as expected. Yeah gr8 deal.
No club will be able to get gr8 deals all the time,deals has lots of factor that decide its price. We wanted Dembele and he was gonna cost a very fiendly deal and he said no. Umtiti forced his way to us,same for Rakitic. That is why those were gr8 deals. Same for Gundogan too btw as he wanted Pep all the way.
So yeah,you are gonna find some gr8 deals,but no big club will be able to operate solely on such kind of deals.
 

Chong Li

New member
His only useful signings are Umtiti and maybe Denis.

Arda, Vidal, Paco and Gomes are a waste of 100+M.

Shambolic. Way worse than Zubinepto.
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
I remember suggesting kante in the transfer thread.
I was attacked right away

You also suggested an absolute crazy team formation that didn't make any sense whatsoever yesterday so I'd argue you might have gotten criticized because of your general suggestions.
 
F

FlaFCB

Guest
1-His job is to make this team good not to make Messi win the bdor. Even if both coincide but we have to get our priorities right
2-We don't know if he has any obsession with Cancelo,it is a tabloid rumor and IIRC Sport is the one behind it. There is nothing to proof we are really after him. He has proven he can keep his cards close and media at man y time proved to be clueless regarding his real plans
3-We will see how the long term of his deals will work out. So far it is a mixed results. He should have skipped getting a striker when target A,B,C rejected us instead of going to the available. If you don't count Denis as he was basically on expensive loan we had 3 of our signings outside of Liga and he is expanding our market. Umtiti is good signing. Digne for me is solid for the price and back up role. Gomes remain to be seen (always liked him as a player but never believed he will fit here) .
Overall he basically signed players for almost every position most of us believed we need signings. Lucho didn't seem to decide to freeze Vidal in pre-season so Roberto-Vidal seemed legit tbh. Many also believed midfield is priority and that is why Gomes was signed

He's failing big at his job. And you forgot paco, another valencia player. I never thought bo-vidal would be so legit, strange they did.
 

LeeRomeno

Active member
Is he a Mendes agent? :thinking:

Signing gomes isntead of a proper rb is really weird. The obsession with Cancelo... And all that is hurting Barça, and will ultimately hurt Messi, making cr more likely to win the bdor next year again.

You should read your own quotes in this thread, if the original signings made sense and you liked them, there is no reason to bash the guy just because they have not been able to merge into the team as well as people hoped. It is not his fault lol.
I am 100% convinced that big majority of Barca fans globally were HAPPY and satisfied after summer transfer and were praising this guy, it is remarkable to start calling him "Mendez" agent and caring about as irrelevant thing as bdor while season is not even halfway there.
 
F

FlaFCB

Guest
You should read your own quotes in this thread, if the original signings made sense and you liked them, there is no reason to bash the guy just because they have not been able to merge into the team as well as people hoped. It is not his fault lol.
I am 100% convinced that big majority of Barca fans globally were HAPPY and satisfied after summer transfer and were praising this guy, it is remarkable to start calling him "Mendez" agent and caring about as irrelevant thing as bdor while season is not even halfway there.

I'm not paid millions to do his job, sadly. I also try to be optimistic, and gave him some trust as I was hoping he knew what he was doing with the players he brought in. After all, he's the pro, not me. But the current obsession with another mendes and valencia player is what is making me wonder that.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top